The Celebrity Traitors: I think Richard E. Grant and Maya Jama have missed a trick
This article contains spoilers from the first episode of The Celebrity Traitors 2026 – you have been warned!
Self-confessed traitor Richard E. Grant might have stolen the show on the opening night of The Celebrity Traitors, but I think he and Maya Jama have already missed an opportunity.
Their first big decision, as traitors, was to choose two contestants for a secret meeting – knowing one would be recruited and the other would be murdered.
They picked comedian James Acaster and journalist Amol Rajan, who took it in turns to plead for their life and state their case as to why they should become a traitor.


But having watched Ross Kemp grow increasingly suspicious of perfectly ordinary interactions, I couldn’t help thinking they had overlooked an obvious target.
If you want to get the heat off yourself, why not murder someone who has already pointed the finger elsewhere?
Ross spent much of the opening episode behaving as though he had wandered into a crime scene. Bella Ramsey putting a sailor hat on a fellow actor became a potential act of ‘murder in plain sight’. Even a rub on the arm from singer Leigh-Anne Pinnock was cause for concern.
His paranoia was entertaining. For the traitors, it could also have been useful.


Had Ross become their first victim, his suspicions about Leigh-Anne and Bella might suddenly have looked rather more significant to the surviving faithfuls.
An innocent interaction is easy to dismiss while the person worrying about it is still sitting beside you. When that person fails to appear at breakfast, there is every chance someone starts asking whether they were onto something.
It would not prove anything, of course. But this is The Traitors. Proof is rarely required before a perfectly innocent contestant finds themselves trying to explain a facial expression or an unfortunate phrase.
Ross had already supplied a possible story. Richard and Maya could have let the faithfuls run with it.


Instead, they chose James and Amol for a face-to-face encounter.
As television, it was a cracking twist. The sight of the pair lying in coffins while awaiting their fate made for a suitably theatrical finish, before the episode left us hanging over the traitors’ decision.
The gameplan was to take suspicion away from Richard.
In the opening episode’s most jaw-dropping moment, the actor told Joe Lycett that he was a traitor. This did not look like a carefully calculated bluff. He appeared so excited about being chosen that he simply couldn’t keep it to himself.
He played it off as a joke, but the bombshell immediately raised eyebrows – including Amol’s.
However, the idea that he was simply acting out because he had not been chosen, despite wanting the role, seemed to give him useful cover. He was clearly loving every moment, and his enjoyment was infectious.
That makes me wonder: would murdering Amol really help their cause? If someone who reacted suspiciously to Richard’s confession suddenly fails to appear at breakfast, the surviving faithfuls might have good reason to revisit that exchange.
Perhaps their eventual recruit will be so good that the decision pays off. We have yet to see who joins them and who becomes their first victim.
Meanwhile, Crawley’s Romesh Ranganathan provided exactly the dry humour I was expecting.
The comedian and TV presenter admitted to feeling unusually nervous and full of adrenaline.
His assessment of his own poker face was particularly funny: “No one can read me, I’ve got a resting indifferent face.”
Romesh also wasted little time in making a joke at Julie Hesmondhalgh’s expense. After she was voted the most trustworthy contestant, he described the prospect of her ending up in a coffin as a ‘win win’. Trust Romesh to turn a vote of confidence into an insult.
There was also the wonderfully questionable detective work of checking how many carbohydrates people were eating as a possible clue to their allegiance.
His exchanges with good friend and fellow comedian Rob Beckett were another highlight. Both honestly said they were not traitors, while making it clear their friendship was on the line if either was lying.
Maya mentioned Romesh as a possible contender for recruitment / murder, but he escaped the final selection and heads into Friday’s episode clear of that particular cliffhanger.
There was plenty to enjoy in this opener: Richard’s mischief, Romesh’s one-liners and Ross finding sinister intent in the smallest gestures.
But the latter’s paranoia could have served a purpose beyond making us laugh.
He had already planted suspicion. I think the traitors should have taken the chance to make it grow.
The Celebrity Traitors continues at 8pm on Friday (October 2) on BBC One.
