Councillors back refusal of controversial housing development near Ringmer
Councillors say controversial plans for a major housing development near Ringmer should be refused.
Lewes District Council’s planning committee, on August 5, considered an outline application to build up to 180 homes on Turnpike Farm greenfield land to the east of Broyle Side.
The committee concluded the application, from land promoter Richborough, should be refused.
The precise wording of this proposed refusal was delegated to officers, but councillors said it should cover matters of landscape impact and highway safety.


Earlier in the meeting, the committee had received legal advice warning how a refusal carried a “significant risk” of costs being awarded should the decision be taken to appeal.
Rowan Clapp, an independent barrister acting as the committee’s legal counsel, said the site is proposed for inclusion in the emerging local plan and had been recommended for approval by council planning officers.
Mr Clapp said: “Were the matter to proceed to appeal, from a legal perspective, there is a significant risk that an adverse cost award would be made against the local authority on the basis of a refusal, given that background.”
He added: “That is not a slap on the wrist and could reflect the local authority being required to pay many hundreds of thousands of pounds for refusing the development.”
In making their recommendation to approve, council planning officers said the council’s housing land supply figure results in a “tilted balance” in favour of the development going ahead, as a result of national planning rules.
These rules require the drawbacks of a proposal to “significantly and demonstrably outweigh the benefits” before a refusal is justified.
Committee members reached the view that the scheme’s harms reached this threshold.
The council is required to inform the government of its proposed decision to give the secretary of state the option to call in the application and potentially make an alternative decision.
Cllr Becky Francomb (Lib Dem) said at the meeting: “We talk about the tilted balance, but my understanding is that as councillors we are decision makers and we are free to attribute weighting to harms and benefits.
“It seems to me — through talking particularly about landscape, sustainability [and] disproportionate growth — that the harms did appear to outweigh the benefits.”
She added: “We are in a position that is not of our making. The planning system is broken. Therefore, if we can’t sort it out, perhaps it should go back to the secretary of state but with that advice: that we have actually looked at the tilted balance and found that these … harms do outweigh the benefits.”
The application had only been seeking outline planning permission with all details other than access (via a new junction on the B2192) to be determined at a later stage.
However, the application included indicative plans showing how the development could contain: 14 one-bedroom units; 58 two-bedroom units; 88 three-bedroom units; and 20 four-bedroom units.