Councillors make ‘constitutional deferral’ on East Hoathly housing plan
The outcome of a major housing application in East Hoathly remains uncertain.
On Thursday (May 21), Wealden District Council’s Majors Planning Committee considered proposals, which could result in as many as 292 homes being built on sites around the village.
The committee had been preparing to vote on a motion to refuse planning permission, when the meeting was adjourned as a result of constitutional concerns linked to a councillor’s comments.
The comments had been made by Independent councillor Kevin Benton and were linked to an objection from East Sussex Highways.


Councillors had previously heard how the applicant, Hesmonds Stud Ltd, had provided evidence in response to this objection.
The officer’s view was that the developer had provided sufficient evidence to show the objection could be overcome through conditions.
But Cllr Benton took issue with this evidence, saying: “If you employ somebody to write a report, they will write the report you want them to. It is as clear as that. So I don’t really carry, never have carried, any weight to reports funded by applicants.”
The council’s development management Samuel Batchelor warned Cllr Benton that he had risked “prejudicing himself quite significantly” through his comments.
Councillors are required to make planning decisions with an open mind.
Cllr Benton said his position was a personal view and based on his experience as a “precision engineer” who had been called upon to act as an expert witness in the past.
But the committee heard how the council’s constitution required the committee to vote on a deferral, “where there is concern about the validity of the reasons and/or officer concern about a potential award of costs on appeal”.
Mr Batchelor said: “To be clear, the reasons you provided … are not the issue.
“The issue as I see it are Cllr Benton’s comments, which … I think have been aired in a way that I think is undermining the decision-making process.”
He added: “It is a vote that needs to be taken chair, it is within the gift of the committee to agree that or not.”
When put to the vote the committee agreed to the deferral.
The application itself is described as a “hybrid” scheme, as it seeks both outline and full planning permission from the council.
The outline element of the application seeks permission to build up to 275 homes on two separate parcels of land referred to as Site A and Site B.
Site A comprises around 37.7 hectares of land to the south east of the village centre. The application seeks permission to build up to 176 dwellings on this land, as well as a two-form entry primary school.
Site B extends to approximately 6.8 hectares to the south of London Road. The application seeks permission to build up to 99 homes on this land.
The application also seeks full planning permission to build 17 homes on land to the east of South Street. The council had previously approved very similar plans to develop this final site.
For further information on the proposals see application reference WD/2025/0376/MAJ on the Wealden District Council website.