Horsham MP warns new government powers could risk more tragic deaths

Liberal Democrat MP for Horsham, John Milne, has warned that sweeping new powers in the Public Authorities (Fraud, Error, and Recovery) Bill could have "tragic consequences" for vulnerable claimants, citing cases where DWP errors have contributed to deaths.
The Bill, which Mr Milne scrutinised as a member of the Bill Committee, would grant the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) unprecedented access to claimants' bank accounts and new powers to recover overpayments.
Speaking in Parliament yesterday during the debate, Mr Milne raised serious concerns about whether adequate safeguards exist to protect people from DWP mistakes.
He recounted the case of Philippa Day, who died aged 27 after the DWP refused her request for an at-home assessment despite knowing she had severe agoraphobia. A coroner identified 28 separate failings by the DWP and its private assessor.
DWP data shows £9.7 billion in benefit overpayments in 2023-24, with around £6.5 billion in Universal Credit alone. Crucially, it's been found that the majority is due to departmental error rather than fraud. Figures show at least 22 DWP contacts relating to possible suicides via the coroner focal point since 2016, and at least 97 claimant-death related internal reviews between 2019 and 2021.
The Horsham MP’s warnings come as local constituents face ongoing struggles with persistent DWP errors that are causing severe financial and emotional strain.
One NHS worker caring for a disabled child has faced incorrect Universal Credit payment calculations consistently for months, despite both HMRC and their employer confirming accurate data. Another local couple were wrongly accused of a £10k overpayment, which was overturned at tribunal, and now face overpayment clawbacks following their migration to Universal Credit.
A Horsham constituent affected by DWP error said: “Back in 2017 we made every effort to notify DWP of my employment alongside my role as carer for my husband. They advised that if further information was needed, that they would write to me - they did not, until they were threatening prosecution/prison for the wrongful overpayments of over £10,000.”
“We were both interviewed under caution, despite my husband's health issues, and it was a very distressing period of months before I could attend a tribunal to represent our position. The error was highlighted very quickly, and the Judge was frustrated that the DWP could provide no evidence that it was anything other than a gross error on their part and a decision was made in our favour.”
John Milne, Liberal Democrat MP for Horsham, said: “I'm seeing firsthand in Horsham how DWP errors are causing severe distress to families who are just trying to get by. The biggest cause of overpayment is departmental error, not fraud. With the DWP's track record of poorly handled mistakes, it's wildly optimistic to assume everything will suddenly be fine.”
“These aren't just statistics; they're real people, including families caring for disabled children, trapped in a nightmare of repeated errors. We need proper safeguards and transparency, including automatic publication of coroners' reports where the DWP has been involved. These errors have contributed to tragic consequences, something we must ensure never happens again.”