Gwyn Jones Farm Diary: No stone left unturned in Farm Profitability Review


Just before Christmas the long awaited ‘Farm Profitability Review’ report from Baroness Minette Batters came out and I read the executive summary straight away, but the 150-page report took a little longer. First of all, let me say that no stone has been left unturned by Minette in her quest to try and find solutions. There are indeed 57 recommendations which are looking to boost the profitability of the sector: far too many to list here.
The report starts with leaving the EU with no plan, that there were three choices for Defra. Use the farming budget to regulate the environment, or secondly allow farmers to be globally competitive, unsubsidised but on a level playing field with the rest of the world, or thirdly find a middle ground, developing a strategy to start a 25 year Farming Roadmap to drive more profitable farming in a way that also delivers on government priorities, benefiting taxpayers and consumers. It’s the latter that she then remains focused on for the remainder of the report.
She admits that the sheer number of asks in her consultations with industry was over 400, symbolic she says of the problems the industry has, and she does in her report focus on some quick wins such as more workers, ability to build water dams and so on. She puts her finger on the pulse immediately in the report when she states that when the Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food was merged with Environment into Defra, we lost focus, expertise, the importance of our industry at government level since that fateful day June 2001.
She dwells on the effect of Brexit, but with half the farmers wanting to leave and the NFU doing nothing at the time to put the bare facts (which we all knew) before their members when she was there at the time, it’s a bit late for that. She also presents endless charts of average farm incomes and different ways of looking at it all, and how the end of the EU payments has now put a huge number of farms at risk.
I’m afraid that there is no going back on Brexit, although some improvements on trade and business dealings are being made which will help, and therefore we only have our own UK Government to fall back on, and we know that Westminster is not that interested in agriculture historically. The real issue here, is that we are in the main commodity producers. That is why cereal markets are on the floor and dairy prices collapsing this winter, oversupply globally. Our problem in the UK is that we cannot compete globally due to lack of scale, huge regulation burden, higher standards, and higher costs.
Minette looks a great deal at what is happening in other countries and shows how training and partnership with government works there. Unfortunately, they are countries where two things are so very different, agriculture matters and they are exporting nations with a clear focus. On our farms, everyone does things differently, we are in the main dominated by processors and food companies who are in turn dominated by big retailers. The huge difference in fixed costs, production output, efficiency, business acumen and so on across British Farms is huge and although farmers leave each year it does not seem to narrow this chasm.
Farming unions try and look after everyone and whilst the strong leaders make progress, they are more often than not hampered by their membership in having to thump the table with the same messages and are held back from radical change. With weaker leadership, credibility and relations with government collapse and with that their influence. The progressive farmers have less to do with their activities and the noisy ones gain influence. That was tolerable if unhelpful whilst we were in the EU, but since Brexit it is a disaster.
We are now well into the transition phase of British agriculture in this country but will not be out the other side until 2029. We are therefore at our weakest and most vulnerable at a time of great instability in the world. Government should worry about food security at this time and history could be about to repeat itself yet again. If ever there was a time to take stock of British agriculture, it is now.
Europe in the main is led by weak leaders, they talk tough but fail to do much. I am afraid that Putin has their measure and whilst they have combined economies 10 times the size of Russia, he seems to be calling the shots. It is incredible to me that frozen Russian money is not going to be used to finance the war effort and then later re-build Ukraine. It is after all Putin who has launched an illegal war on Ukraine, and we worry about the legalities, and global investors, when natural justice should take president.
I wouldn’t mind if the European leaders and I include the UK of course, did not make such warmongering statements, when they shy away at the first challenge. It is easy to be tough when it’s someone else spilling blood. Our own defence chiefs talk of the need to be prepared. Who is he addressing? This country can’t help itself, never mind anyone else, unless we have a badly needed re-set of priorities and values. Whilst our leaders are seeing wolves at the door, they continue to have their priorities completely wrong, fattening the welfare lamb rather than spending on defence in a meaningful way.
Whilst our economy is stubbornly flat lining, every day we see reported in the press and media why house building is not going ahead, regulation, planning issues, ridiculous demands by environmental and nature groups. Our greedy doctors are on strike again, causing maximum disruption, trivia surrounds us whilst people suffer. A hawk to stop pigeons defecating all over a food market is instantly opposed by some group or other, everywhere you look there is someone with a placard!
The state of our liberal democracy should now concern us all, its not just the inability to get people into work and getting the economy going again, but our progressive politics is taking us into some disturbing and dark places. We seem unable to police protests, stamp out undesirable and illegal slogans, clamp down on divisive doctrines, which are all over the largely unregulated social media. Free speech is one thing and we all defend that, but we are entering a very dangerous period if we cannot control some of the things which are going on.
Our political leaders are as divided as ever, when in fact they should be for once pulling together on such important issues, which will shape our very future. You will gather from this that I don’t think 2025 has been a very good year, but I am an optimist and hope that in 2026 we can start to put things right and turn this country around, after all it is very much in all our interest.
A young lady was telling me the other day how she lives with her mum and money is tight, a familiar story. She then told me her mum bought chicken or dog food every day to feed four or five foxes who visit her garden every evening. That is 2025 UK!
A Happy New Year to all our readers.