'I have never seen the community so united' - Campaigners celebrate after West Sussex village housing plan withdrawn

Residents across the Manhood Peninsula are celebrating after plans to build hundreds of homes in East Wittering were withdrawn.

Barratt David Wilson Homes withdrew its planning application for 268 new homes on agricultural land at Stubcroft Farm, East Wittering – a proposal that locals, conservationists and councillors had united to oppose as ‘wholly inappropriate’ for one of West Sussex’s ‘most ecologically sensitive and vulnerable coastal areas’.

Campaigners say they hope the latest news ‘brings to a close several years of developer pressure on the site’. A previous application for 280 homes was unanimously refused by Chichester District Council in September 2023 and a subsequent appeal was dismissed by a Planning Inspector in November 2024

“I have lived here for over thirty years and I have never seen the community so united,” resident Antonia Doggart said.

Barratt David Wilson Homes withdrew its planning application for 268 new homes on agricultural land at Stubcroft Farm, East Wittering – a proposal that locals, conservationists and councillors had united to oppose as ‘wholly inappropriate’ for one of West Sussex’s ‘most ecologically sensitive and vulnerable coastal areas’. (Photo contributed)placeholder image
Barratt David Wilson Homes withdrew its planning application for 268 new homes on agricultural land at Stubcroft Farm, East Wittering – a proposal that locals, conservationists and councillors had united to oppose as ‘wholly inappropriate’ for one of West Sussex’s ‘most ecologically sensitive and vulnerable coastal areas’. (Photo contributed)

“Hundreds of us wrote letters, attended meetings, turned up to hearings. It was exhausting — but it worked. When residents speak with one voice, they cannot be ignored.

"The fundamental geographical problems with this site cannot go away at a developer’s whim. You cannot engineer your way out of a coastal flood plain.”

Applicant Barratt David Wilson Homes sought permission from Chichester District Council in May 2024 to build on land at Stubcroft Farm.

The application – along with a previous one refused by the council in 2023 – attracted hundreds of objections, with flooding and sewage sitting at the top of a long list of concerns.

Izabela Mayne – Liberal Democrat county council candidate for the Witterings – praised the work of Chichester district councillors ‘in the face of considerable pressure’.placeholder image
Izabela Mayne – Liberal Democrat county council candidate for the Witterings – praised the work of Chichester district councillors ‘in the face of considerable pressure’.

The council twice permitted the applicant more time to look into the flooding issues and – given its similar concerns about the previous application – was likely on the way to refusing this one.

Almost two years after the plans were submitted, agent Henry Adams LLP wrote to the council withdrawing the application – but that does mean another will not be submitted at a later date.

The letter read: “This decision has been made in the spirit of continuing to work positively and collaboratively with the council.

“While we remain confident that the matters raised in respect of the applications can be addressed and resolved, we recognise the time already afforded by the council in considering the proposals to date.

“Given the current position and acknowledging that further extensions of time are not possible, it is considered appropriate to withdraw the applications at this stage.

“This will allow the opportunity to reflect on the feedback received and to engage further with the council.”

Izabela Mayne – Liberal Democrat county council candidate for the Witterings – praised the work of Chichester district councillors ‘in the face of considerable pressure’.

"I want to take my hat off to our district councillors, who listened carefully to the concerns of local residents and showed real backbone in recognising that this was a totally unsustainable application from the very beginning,” she said.

"They stood firm through a bruising appeal process and were ultimately proved right.”

Iain Ballantyne, district councillor for the Witterings ward, played a central role in the original refusal and appeal. He said he was pleased with the community’s collective efforts.

“This site was always wrong for housing,” he said.

"The evidence on flooding alone should have been enough to deter any responsible developer. I am proud that the council listened to residents, applied the evidence rigorously, and held its position throughout.”

Critics of the development have argued that Stubcroft Farm was simply the wrong place to build. The 16.9-hectare site – currently Grade 2 agricultural land comprising productive arable fields – faced objections on multiple grounds that together painted a picture of a fundamentally unsustainable location.

The ‘most powerful argument’ against development, they say, was the site’s ‘vulnerability to future inundation’.

There were also fears about the impact a housing development would have on the nearby, sustainable Stubcroft Farm campsite.

Residents and business owners warned that large-scale housing development on the approach to the village would ‘permanently damage the area’s character and its appeal to visitors’ – with ‘serious economic consequences for local hospitality and retail businesses’.

Residents also pointed out that sewage capacity was already at breaking point.

A spokesperson for the campaigners added: “The addition of 268 new homes – potentially adding hundreds of new connections to a system already under strain – was a serious concern for residents and parish councillors alike.

"Several speakers at planning hearings pointed to the embarrassment of sewage discharges into local watercourses in recent years as evidence that the system simply could not absorb further pressure without significant – and costly – upgrades."

To view the application, log on to publicaccess.chichester.gov.uk and search for 26/00323/FUL.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice