Gwyn Jones Farm Diary: Budget was a disappointment, as expected


I’m afraid the budget was as expected a disappointment for farmers, and especially the NFU. The Inheritance Tax stays , but an important concession has now allowed 100% relief on spousal transfer, as Defra Ministers tell the industry to ‘move on’. Farmers had arrived on foot and one group had brought along an old RAF fuel tank which looked like a rocket.
Numerous people were arrested, having driven dozens of tractors into London, defying a police ban on agricultural vehicles. All they can do now is wait another 4 years and hope for a change of government, one which will abolish the IT on farms, although once these taxes are baked in, they tend to stay, despite promises.
What of the rest of the budget? Well, I’m afraid it was a lash-up of measures, playing to Labour backbenchers, guided not by strategy but mere expediency. More welfare and more taxes, but I don’t expect that Labour backbenchers will be happy for long and the pressure on both the Prime Minister and Chancellor will return.
Largely hidden due to the budget noise last week were the farm income figures which were very good, up 49% on average at £71,200 per farm. This average figure cover a huge range, from £40,300 for less favoured areas (LFA), to £235,900 for specialist poultry units. The important average mixed farm income jumped by 156% to £58,000 and with inflation taken into account, farm incomes were the highest in 20 years. This should be something to celebrate as it does not happen that often, and I’m afraid makes the NFU look very silly, losing credibility with all the doom and gloom, and is very sad to see.
Lowland and LFA incomes are at their highest ever, whilst cereal farmers have been the real losers in all this with average incomes below £50,000 for the second year in a row, with a quarter of cereal farms operating at a loss. There have only been 4 years in the past 20, when incomes have been lower in real terms, and they are currently heading in another year of low returns due to cereal prices and weather. As usual there are plenty of examples of farmers working for very little reward, with a third of horticulture businesses losing money, and plenty of farms working all hours operating at £25,000 or less which is now the minimum wage for a 40-hour week.
However, 24% of all farms made an income of over £100,000 with 69% of pig units, 51% of dairy farms and 37% of arable farms above that figure. Income from non farming diversification and Agri-environment schemes added to general income on many farms, as the remnants of the old EU BPS scheme made a big difference. That scheme will be gone next year and that will certainly matter to many farmers.
Looking to the future, if global cereal production remains high, prices will be depressed and many cereal farmers in the UK will consider their position. Dairy farmer numbers have fallen over the years and will continue to do so, but I expect production to remain at around the same level. Beef and lamb prices are good and if that is not undermined by imports, I can see farmers who have scale and are good technical operators remaining in profit. Pigs and poultry are very different, a few large scale producers dominating, largely processing companies who own over half the pig industry now and in poultry, farmers who are contracted to large processors being looked after.
Horticulture is the one sector the government wants to grow, more fruit and veg in the diet is also an often-heard rallying cry. However, this sector is dominated by huge retail buyers and are desperate for some action. Guy Singh-Watson, the founder of Riverford has been calling for a regulator with teeth for a long time now. Relations with supermarkets have deteriorated recently and some action is needed, with almost all growers stating that they have been victims of unfair practice at some point. Guy Singh -Watson commented that farming should not feel like survival, asking how farmers can do the right thing for the soil, their animals and the planet if they lack the funds to invest.
COP30 took place recently, and progression in alternative technologies and fuels to power British Agriculture was hotly debated. One of the greatest innovators in this country has been JCB, with Lord Bamford who is now 80, at the helm. Their investment in Hydrogen combustion is very likely to be the future power of agricultural tractors and heavy plant on construction sites and not battery power.
The Bamford family business started making agricultural tipping farm trailers in 1945, and has grown into a global powerhouse, in fact the world’s third largest construction equipment manufacturer, selling to more than 150 countries and generating £5.7 billion in annual turnover. The Hydrogen engine is the answer to how heavy machinery is powered in remote locations, working 12-hour shifts without fossil fuel. It’s a very simple answer in essence, as the current engines are adapted to run on Hydrogen instead of diesel.
Diesel technology they know well and has worked well for decades. They build and service them, and the Hydrogen version is very similar, using the same pistons, cylinders, crankshaft and fuelling systems. The only difference being the fuel itself, which emits zero carbon emissions with only steam coming out of the exhaust. These engines cope with dirty conditions and work at extreme temperature, and more than 130 engines have now been built, powering various plant machinery.
Lord Bamford foresees a future where Hydrogen engines replace diesel engines in agriculture with minimal disruption, Hydrogen tanks taking the place of diesel tanks on farms. That would be a first in the race to cut emissions, but if one company can do it, JCB is that company.
The Bamford’s who also farm 3400 acres organically and are looking forward to re-engineering and retro fitting current trucks with Hydrogen engines, diesel trucks which will otherwise be emitting for many years to come. The company’s philosophy is to not to throw everything away and start again with electric, but to make use of the perfectly functional vehicles we have but change the power source. These are the technological solutions which will get us to where we want to be without ruining the economy and risk turning people against the drive for lower emissions.
Whilst the government’s flagship policy of building 1.5 million homes during this parliament is unlikely to succeed, more obstacles are being put in the way by the usual suspects. The Wildlife Trusts and RSPB are claiming that the planning bill, which is badly needed in order to get on with the job of building, would strip species of their protection. They claim that the public do not want nature to be sacrificed for short term growth, a gross misrepresentation of what is proposed.
However, this example of getting our priorities in a muddle pales into insignificance next to the ‘Nuclear fish disco’. More than £700 million is being spent on Hinkley Point C nuclear power station, giving the plant in Somerset the highest fish protection measures in the world. This colossal amount of money will apparently save 0.083 salmon and 0.028 trout per year with its acoustic fish deterrent, nicknamed the disco, using noise to keep the fish away from the cooling system. This country has gone completely mad, that is for sure.