Gwyn Jones Farm diary: Facing huge challenges in agriculture


You will not see sympathy for a government of any colour in this column very often, but I am happy to praise as well as criticise, when I feel there is merit in doing so. What we are about to witness is very different, and it has happened before with the Covid pandemic and the Russian invasion of the Ukraine. We are about to see the small increments of change since the government came into power, the green shoots as they were once called, completely wiped out by events that are completely out of its control.
This green tinge, as it is little more than that, is the prospect of inflation coming down further, interest rates coming down again, lower energy bills, and all due to the Chancellor’s stabilising policies for the economy. We can agree or disagree on the difficult choices this government has made, and I disagree with many of them, however, I don’t have any easy answers.
Despite Covid and Putin’s war in the Ukraine, the last government did at least have 14 years and despite that, handed over a terrible legacy to Keir Starmer. Two years on, its time to move on, but I am afraid that we are going to see all efforts obliterated by the Middle East conflict and whilst not to blame, this government will carry the can. It will also mean that we will not get the opportunity to see the effect of this government’s policies, and whether they might have improved things, and if so, by how much.
We are desperately short of talent in Westminster and have been for some time. There are no real political thinkers who advise government, and there is a distinct lack of intellectual heft in all parties. The last Conservative government with its multitude of Prime Ministers was shambolic much of the time and this Labour government has few star players. There are some and its worth looking at them, given that they may well be future leaders. Two Ministers stand out for me, and then there is another Minister who must be mentioned.
Wes Streeting is one of the stars and is doing a competent and sound job of the NHS, despite the doctors and their irresponsible and wicked union, the BMA, who were against the NHS when it was formed in 1948 with 84% of doctors voting against. Aneurin Bevan said at the time that the BMA leadership was politically poisoned, and I am afraid remains so. The NHS only got off the ground due to Bevan buying them off, ‘stuffing their mouths with gold’ as he said at the time. It is time to do something about this running sore in our midst.
The second Minister to impress is the Home Secretary, Shabana Mahmood. It’s too early to judge her success at the Home Office, but she has a grip on the department which is something that has not happened for a very long time despite successive Home Secretaries from both parties. We will see how she gets on, but my biggest fear is that she will be defeated by her own party. If they do, it is likely they will also seal their own fate.
The other minister is Ed Milliband. I and so many others constantly criticise this Net Zero zealot, and yet he carries on. It is incredible how he manages to drive through one harmful policy after another, taking no notice of global events. He is now doubling down to go faster with renewables, totally rejects any change in policy with regard to the North Sea, where we could and should expand operations as the Norwegians are doing. How does he get so much done? Some say that he is still the Labour leader.
We are facing huge challenges in agriculture, just as other businesses are, and I find it worrying that our dependency of fuel, energy and oil derived products is so great. Arable farmers are openly questioning whether they will plant next year’s crop this autumn if things don’t change. Progressive farmers will have bought fuel and fertilizer ahead for this year, others will at least have a good deal of it covered, but no one has it bought for next year. Cereals only make a small profit for the best farmers currently, with many either relying on diversification or a second income.
The arable sector, where the crops are a globally traded commodity in oversupply, is in very real trouble. It can only continue like this for so long and since Brexit, the single farm payment which would enable farmers to hang on has gone. It is now spent of the environment and nature, which is all well and good until there is a shortage of affordable food. This change of policy away from farming was expected (but other promises were believed), the Conservatives started it and this Labour government continues with the madness.
When leading politicians start talking about the need for home-grown food as Kemi Badenoch did last week, you know its too late. There is no magical way of boosting food supply as we have found out twice in the last 120 years when the chips were down. The very least we can expect is that food prices will increase substantially, but shortages will be unlikely in the short term unless retailers get it badly wrong, which they might if their competitive instincts get the better of their treatment of suppliers. This I am confident would be quickly corrected but could nevertheless cause a major issue.
Imports will be more expensive and less reliable should the conflict continue or not be resolved, and given we import 40% of our food, that will be a huge hit for consumers. We have been caught with our trousers down as a country, we have run down and put pressure on every aspect of all the most important things in life which any government should protect, and that includes farming. This has been going on for years, and accelerated of late due to Brexit, covid, the war in the Ukraine, by governments of all colours.
It has been shambolic and such was the dissatisfaction of farmers and ordinary people that they were persuaded to cut ties with our biggest trading partner and go off pretending we were some great trading nation, or a nation of corporate buccaneers, only to do deals which have started harming agriculture in this country with more to come. War in Europe was not in anyone’s mind, never mind a major conflict in the Middle East at the same time.
Re-wilding and hampering farmers with regulation, grazing density, lack of support and prioritising those who think they know best when it comes to the environment and nature is what has followed. Monty Don (of all people) agrees with me! He also rubbishes the re-wilding evangelists, hankering after some arcadian ideal. As he says, long before this country was urbanised, it was farmed, but as we were the first to industrialise, and fundamentally became an urban society, it is not surprising that some hanker after a past where there was this wonderful wild, pure state of trees and woodland everywhere.
It never existed of course and as Monty says, land has been cleared since the Stone Age, and many more trees were felled by axes than chainsaws. This fact does not bother our urban environmentalists who are hell bent on reducing farming activities, but this may be the moment when their dream becomes other people’s nightmare. Farmers are losing confidence and there is now a real danger of disruption.