Horsham Society: The gulls have evolved, could we?


This weeks column by Oliver Farley
Horsham’s park in winter is a haven for black headed gulls, a flock of them often over-winter here, gathering on the grass near the pond. Look too for two other gulls, so ordinary they might escape attention. The Herring gull, Larus argenatus, is a regular sight as is the Lesser Black-backed gull, L. fuscus. Don’t be deceived, these two species raise serious questions both about the definition of a species and about the entanglement of natural elements across the globe.
Here in Horsham park the two species can be observed side by side, though in fact they represent the two ends of a broken circle or what is termed a ring species. The black-backed gull can be followed across Europe and into Russia where it gradually morphs into the Siberian Lesser Black-backed gull, then into L. Heuglin , subsequently into L.Vega and round to L.Simthsonianus and eventually into L. argenatus. While each neighbouring species can successfully interbreed, those birds which are two or more steps apart cannot easily do so.
Richard Dawkins has termed this as evolution in a spatial dimension rather than chronologically. It raises the question of where to draw the definitive line between one species and another and the whole concept of a ring species where neighbours can interbreed but the ends of the ring cannot, has been the subject of vigorous debate among natural historians.
There is a near parallel in the traditions of the Inuit people whose home territory also circles the North Pole, crossing national boundaries and arbitrary divides insouciantly. Being separated into migratory groups they speak whole class of languages known as the Inuit-Yupik-Unangan and share a similar dependence upon natural resources which they follow along well-established pathways in the apparently trackless wastes of the Arctic regions from Siberia to Greenland. They were an interesting curiosity until climate change and global rivalries for mineral riches propelled them to the forefront of acute attention.
That changes are happening in Greenland’s climate and its ice cap is now beyond dispute, and the huge island with its tiny population of about 50,000 is playing a role unwished for in international politics. However these forces may play out, there is the serious problem of the melting ice. Year after year the ice cap has retreated, and more and more cold water is pouring into the oceans. It has been calculated that world sea levels would rise by seven meters if all of it melted.
There is another vexing issue which goes by the clumsy name of the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation. This is a huge network of ocean currents which spans the full extent of the Atlantic and is best known to us as the Gulf Stream. In essence, Britain enjoys a warmer climate than is warranted by its latitude because of ocean currents, which could be cut off by excess cold flows from melting Arctic ice. Britain, and Horsham, would have the climate of Labrador.
The gulls have evolved, could we?
For more information see www.horshamsociety.org