Political opinion with John Milne MP: Benefit fraud needs a balanced approach

John Milne speaking in Parliament on the Public Authorities (Fraud, Error & Recovery) Bill.placeholder image
John Milne speaking in Parliament on the Public Authorities (Fraud, Error & Recovery) Bill.

Last week in Parliament, I spoke to the Fraud, Error and Recovery Bill, a new piece of legislation designed to reduce overpayments in the benefits system. For me, there’s nothing worse than defrauding the benefit system. It hits right at the heart of what is best in our country – our willingness to help others out in times of need. Quite simply, fraud eats away at public support for welfare.

However, the government’s new bill takes far-ranging powers, which have raised concerns. Banks will be required by law to trawl through claimants’ private bank accounts to search for ‘suspicious’ behaviour. The suspicion in the first place will be cast not by a human, but by a computer-driven algorithm.

How much can we trust the DWP (Department of Work & Pensions) to get this right? The fact is that the DWP does not have a good record.

Over the years, the DWP have wrongly pursued thousands of claimants for suspected fraud. In my speech, I quoted the tragic cases of Phillipa Day (27) and Kristie Hunt (31), who both took their own lives following relentless but incorrect DWP harassment. The truth is that most overpayments are actually the result of DWP error, not fraud.

DWP investigations into these tragedies have been less than transparent. To that end, I asked the Minister for the publication of coroner’s reports to become automatic, which is not the case right now.

In promoting this bill, the government is showing far too much blind confidence in DWP administration. There is no sign that the DWP has got a grip of its tendency to make errors. Only this month, it has been revealed that as many as 23,000 families were wrongly targeted in a government crackdown on child benefit fraud and had their benefits cut off.

There is a culture today of always assuming the worst about benefit claimants. But in an area like PIP (Personal Independent Payments), the fraud rate is just 0.2%. That’s so small it barely registers in statistics at all. So why is the government interrogating PIP claimant bank accounts in the same way as UC claimants, where this is a much bigger rate of fraud?

It’s disappointing to see a Labour government getting caught up in the kind of false narrative which normally thrives on the right. We have seen more than enough cases like Phillipa Day and Kristie Hunt.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice