Council defends position on ‘Zionism is racism’ motion
The co-deputy leader of the Green Party has defended her local group’s position on the controversial ‘Zionism is racism’ policy
Speaking on Wednesday (November 18), Wealden District Council leader Rachel Millward, also co-deputy leader of the Green Party of England and Wales, reiterated how the authority’s Green group is opposed to the policy — a position it had set out in previously-published statements.
Cllr Millward had been responding to a question from Reform UK councillor David Greaves, who asked why the council leader had not stepped down from her national role given this opposition.
In asking his question, Cllr Greaves noted how one of the authority’s members — Danehill and Fletching councillor Christine Coleman — had recently resigned from the Green Party as a result of concerns around the policy motion and the ‘party’s direction’.
Cllr Greaves said: “Cllr Millward [has] stated that none of the Green group in Wealden supported the recent Zionism is racism motion … and had publicly said so.
“That being the case I am very surprised that Green Party members sitting in this room have not made a similar decision to that of Cllr Coleman; maybe they feel a token defection will satisfy the electorate that they are not racist and antisemites.
“So, Cllr Millward, if you really disapprove of this vile, racist motion, why have you not shown leadership, acted with your conscience and as a result given up your role as joint party deputy-leader and followed the decent move made by Cllr Coleman?”
In her response — a full recording of which can be found on the council’s website — Cllr Millward set out the reasons why her group did not support the policy motion.
She said: “The policy itself does clearly define Zionism to be political Zionism; the ethnonationalist practice of the current state of Israel – something which is clearly talked about by our current government as involving ethnic cleansing, which the United Nations makes clear involves a genocide – that is what that motion is about and what that motion calls racist.
“However, personally and as a group, we acknowledge that the word Zionism just resonates on many different levels with different people.
“For some it simply means the longing for a homeland and we recognize that the Jewish people feel the pain of this huge intergenerational trauma of a people repeatedly displaced and who suffered the most horrific genocide themselves.
“So we acknowledge that pain and understand the complexity of these terms and don’t feel it is helpful.”
Cllr Millward said her group also disagreed with the part of the policy “which speaks to a single-state solution”.
Despite this disagreement, council leader also disputed Cllr Greaves’ description of the policy.
Cllr Millward said: “I do object to the framing of the question; that it is a racist or antisemitic policy.
“It is so important that we do not conflate anti-Zionism or speaking out against the actions of the state of Israel with antisemitism. That is so unhelpful and so irresponsible.”
She added: “I want to be absolutely clear that there is no discrimination against Jewish people within the policy or within the Green Party.”
Green Party councillor Jessika Hulbert, who was chairing the meeting, declined to allow Cllr Greaves a follow-up question.