Auditors found concerns at Brighton school facing closure

Auditors identified significant failings at a school that is now facing closure, according to a newly published report.

The failings were found in an internal audit which was a follow up after previous checks highlighted 17 areas of concern at Middle Street Primary School, in Brighton.

The failings were found in an internal audit which was a follow up after previous checks highlighted 17 areas of concern at Middle Street Primary School, in Brighton.placeholder image
The failings were found in an internal audit which was a follow up after previous checks highlighted 17 areas of concern at Middle Street Primary School, in Brighton.

When the follow up audit took place, in the autumn term, several problems were still to be adequately addressed. A report said: “Actions were required to

  • declare and effectively manage conflicts of interest
  • improve financial controls regarding raising purchase orders, evidence of monthly payroll approval and maintaining a contract register
  • improve the process of new starters to ensure that all pre-employment checks are completed and appropriate information is retained to evidence this
  • improve the process of exit interviews for staff leavers to ensure feedback and insight is shared appropriately with senior leadership and
  • maintain and implement a data protection policy

“At the time of the audit the school was being governed through an interim executive board (IEB), approved by the Department for Education in June 2025.”

The initial audit was carried out as the school’s financial position was deteriorating under head teacher Rob Cooper and the governors who were replaced last June. The school leadership at that time was criticised at a recent council meeting.

The concerns were spelt out in an “internal audit and counter fraud” progress report relating to the final three months of last year – from October to December.

They are due to be presented to Brighton and Hove City Council’s Audit, Standards and General Purposes Committee at Hove Town Hall next week.

The report to councillors said: “Our review found that 11 of the 17 actions arising from the previous audit had been implemented.

“The issues raised during the audit relate to transactions and recruitment that occurred before the IEB. We note that since the IEB has been in place controls have gradually improved.”

The school became the first in Brighton and Hove to have an IEB appointed in place of the previous board of governors – a move only permitted when a school is causing concern.

The appointment of an IEB has to be signed off by the Education Secretary – and in the case of Middle Street it followed a series of problems.

Parents raised safeguarding concerns about the school and its leadership – and some withdrew their children from the school as a result.

High staff turnover fuelled agency costs for supply cover, contributing to a financial deficit that has soared to more than £400,000. The school’s annual budget has been about £1 million.

Funding is broadly based on pupil numbers and the falling number of children at the school has made the deficit almost impossible to repay.

While many parents welcomed the arrival of the IEB, some have said that if the council had acted sooner in appointing the board, it might have been possible to save the school.

A final decision on whether to close the school – the oldest school in Brighton and Hove – is due to be made at a special council meeting on Thursday 21 May.

Neither internal audit report has been published. The findings of the latest report are included in the agenda papers for the council’s next Audit, Standards and General Purposes Committee meeting.

The committee is due to meet at Hove Town Hall at 4pm next Tuesday (21 April). The meeting is scheduled to be webcast.

Related topics:
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice