Decision to close Worthing care home is supported by a West Sussex County Council scrutiny committee
The decision to close a Worthing care home has been supported by a West Sussex County Council scrutiny committee.
Opinion about the closure of New Tyne, in Durrington, was divided during a meeting of the Health & Adult Social Care Scrutiny Committee on Friday (November 21), with the final say on whether to oppose the closure going to the chair.
The decision to close was taken by Amanda Jupp, cabinet member for adults services, in September but was called in by Labour leader Chris Oxlade.
Mr Oxlade praised the care and stability the home provided for elderly people with dementia. He added: “Closing New Tyne would inflict unnecessary harm on these vulnerable people, disrupt dedicated staff and ignore the overwhelming opposition from families and the local community.”


That opposition was reflected in a petition submitted to the council, which was signed by around 2,500 people, along with a list of more than 30 views from families, friends, councillors, and some of the 27 staff.
Among those views were concerns that the process to close New Tyne had not been fair or transparent, that something could be done to adapt unused space in the building for other uses, and questioning the financial rationale for the closure.
That rationale included the £1.46m which the council said would be needed for the maintenance of the building over the next 10 years, on top of any upgrades to meet future changes in regulation.
Mrs Jupp gave an impassioned speech defending her decision and laying out the council’s dire financial situation.


She said: “It will be difficult, I realise that – it is a very emotional decision. But I have to tell you, there’s no money available in our capital budget. We do not have any money to do anything to New Tyne.”
Mrs Jupp told the meeting that adults services was currently running at an overspend of £12m – a gap that needed to be closed by the end of the financial year if the council was to meet its legal requirement to present a balanced budget.
She added: “We will be making savings in all sorts of places. We have to look at everything – and if this decision is not taken, then we will probably have to make cuts elsewhere.”
The budget for New Tyne was set based on 15 long-stay beds being occupied. There are currently 12 people staying there.
Mrs Jupp stressed that, in the 51 care homes in Worthing, 40 per cent of the beds catered for specialist dementia care.
She added: “This is not a decision I want to take. It is not an easy decision. But I have looked at the finances.”
A report to the committee said the usual cost for a dementia bed in the Worthing area in 2025/26 is around £945 per week. At New Tyne it is £1,532. The closure is expected to deliver savings of £460,000 per year.
As for the residents, their carers and families, she pledged that they would receive support from the council now and in the future, adding: “They won’t just be dropped in a home and left – that would be the last thing we’d do.”
James Walsh (Lib Dem, Littlehampton East) tabled a proposal that the process be paused for a wider public consultation, and for exploration of ways of making use of the whole building.
The vote was tied at 4-4, leaving chair Alison Cooper (Con, Rustington) to use her casting vote to oppose the proposal.