Questions asked about Horsham District Council’s aim to spend £2.6m on construction of community facilities
Questions have been asked about Horsham District Council’s aim to spend £2.6m on the construction of community facilities in Highwood.
A report into plans for a community hall, changing rooms, toilets and car park was brought to a scrutiny committee meeting on Monday (September 1) by chairman Paul Clarke, ‘because the finances don’t stack up’.
The changing rooms, toilets and car park have been on the table for a number of years. But the inclusion of the hall in the plans – an addition that will cost £700,000 – caused some concern, not least with the council’s chief finance officer (CFO).
A report from Jonathan Taylor, cabinet member for enterprise & property, said: “The CFO cannot support this option as there is no financial return and no payback. The CFO recommends that the cost of any facility on this site is kept to a minimum, being just the provision of changing rooms and toilet facilities to enable use of the playing facilities already on site.


“The ‘changing rooms only’ option would cost around £1.9m with revenue costs of around £80,000, due to much lower running costs. Providing a small hall will only exacerbate the ongoing revenue costs and put unnecessary pressure on the council’s forecast future budget gaps.”
The council has already approved £200,000 for detailed design work, and a consultation was held in March to ask the views of residents on what should be done with the site on The Boulevard, opposite Dereham Way.
Mr Clarke said there were ‘a plethora of other public buildings around with plenty of spaces for community use’.
He added: “The questionnaire actually did not cover the issue of the running cost. It just asked ‘would you like this?’ and of course people will say ‘yes of course I’d like this’. Is it fair that we have to cover the cost as a council?”
While the new centre would be run by the council, there are hopes that a third party, such as a community group or organisation, could eventually take over.
Plans had been put in place in 2022 for a community facility and nursery, but they fell through when the nursery pulled out. Tony Hogben (Con, Colgate & Rusper) said the latest plan was ‘appalling in comparison’.
He added: “I’m not saying the people of Highwood don’t deserve a community centre. But if that’s the project scope someone is set with achieving – having a key tenant [such as] the Scouts, a nursery, someone to run that building – without that it becomes a liability with ongoing running costs for the council.”
But Len Ellis-Brown (Green, Pulborough, Coldwaltham & Amberley) pointed out the social and well-being benefits the facility would bring.
He said: “If we continually look at the financial return on what we were doing, we would probably do very little for our communities.”
Belinda Walters (Lib Dem, Roffey North) added: “We made a promise. Those residents were promised a vision, a way to live, and within that was community facility.
“I don’t support not building it. I don’t support challenging the budget that we’ve put forward. I don’t support challenging cabinet against going ahead with this.”
The committee’s views will be passed to a meeting of the cabinet later this month, when a final decision will be taken on whether to approve the project.