REVIEW: Romantic Awakenings concert by Worthing Symphony Orchestra
REVIEW BY Richard Amey. ‘Romantic Awakenings’. Concert by Worthing Symphony Orchestra at The Assembly Hall, Sunday 17 May (2.45), stand-in leader Paul Willey, conductor John Gibbons, piano Julian Chan. Mendelssohn, The Fair Melusine Overture; Bizet, Symphony in C; Tchaikovsky, Piano Concerto No 2 in G, 2nd movement string soloists Paul Willey violin, Miriam Lowbury cello.
An emerging Malaysian piano ace delivered a double shock to his captured audience having already astonished them with the executional prowess and expressive power of Tchaikovsky’s second success at writing a Piano Concerto. First, after it ended, he spoke to the crowd at a little length after his bowing – still not the done thing by concerto soloists where the bastions of classical concert culture are resisting longest. Second, he brought the news that Bizet was also a beautiful composer for the piano.
With a physical build at the slender end of westerners’ perception of the conventional Buddha scale of personal weight, and not very tall either, Julian Chan’s voice was a deep one. That surprise accompanied this shock No 1. So did these words – uttered to the audience with a broad smile: “I hope you enjoyed that as much as I did!” (Should he not have been exhausted beyond words? And if not, why not?). And surprising also was that, to reach a microphone he had to lower, he’d now stepped up onto the hallowed conductor’s rostrum.
He thanked the WSO director John Gibbons and the orchestral musicians, and then he invited the crowd out somewhere with him – to his International Interview Concert a week later St Symphorian’s Durrington Hill, where he “will be playing a bit of Beethoven and Chopin, and two composers close to my heart, Alkan and Godowsky.” He forgot to include Schubert, but see the listing below at 24 May for all the details of what offers classical fans chance to watch, hear and meet Chan in much greater close-up, gathered around the piano and the chairs and coffee table hosting the conversations he’ll have, including with the audience.
Shock No 1 was less cataclysmic than it would have been at other orchestral concerts where audiences are denied verbal contact – unlike John Gibbons’ WSO supporters, who for at least 12 years have warmed to his deliberate cultivation of his audience to learn more via his spoken rapport about the music, and life in general. He now has an enlightened, broader-minded, more trusting crowd than a great many other provincial concert series.
The door is open to survival now for classical music along this path. Old-school classical followers are rapidly dying off and with them their elitist indifference to the servant live performers themselves, in preference to their own private communion with the music and its composers. After them now, the classical concert halls are peopled principally by the first postwar generation, whose musical upbringing was blown open by the post-Beatles social explosion, soaking them into pop, rock, folk and jazz, along with the subtle, quieter classical links inside those four genres, together with classical encounters with their parents’ record collections that seeded inside their heads and hearts.
Shock No 2? Julian Chan told his audience that to round off this concert WSO called ‘Romantic Awakenings’, he’d leave them with an encore called Daybreak, by Bizet – the creator of Carmen who is almost universally unknown as a piano composer. This was a further insight into Chan as an artist. He’d picked up on Bizet’s earlier presence during the afternoon, and made a revelation of his own. Daybreak is the first of his six narrative songs without words, Songs Of The Rhine. Chan will next season perform all six in his solo piano programmes – a world that lost Bizet to his adamantly preferred career genre of opera before he died at just 37.
Gibbons pinpointed Tchaikovsky’s Piano Concerto No 2 as companion to The Fair Melusine by Mendelssohn in sharing victimhood of classical box office mania. Piano Concerto No 1 owns such total programming sway enough almost to spark conspiracy theories. Piano Concerto No 2 simply can’t level things up without first a worldwide ban on performances, broadcasts and new recordings of No 1.
Frustrated fairy-tale mermaid Melusine fancies a knight she can’t ultimately hang on to because he’s human and she’s not. Beethoven sensed an opera in this. Contractual difficulties scotched that but later, Mendelssohn saw in the story further dramatic overture potential. However, but after initial popularity his Hebrides and A Midsummer Night’s Dream overtures (all three end quietly) now firmly commandeer concert prorgammers’ aims, let alone their affections.
The WSO tenderly shared with us the Melusine overture’s sensualities spotted by father-of-five Mendelssohn, and then they romped through most of Bizet’s miraculous Symphony of a Seventeen-Year-Old. The romping paused for the languid Iberian atmosphere of the slow movement, in which Christopher’s O’Neal’s oboe playing yet again poured European sophistication into the WSO picture painting palette. Not since Ravel’s Le Tombeau de Couperin have WSO fans been as generously treated to O’Neal’s sound at length. Many will feel it’s high time he was called up for his turn at concerto action.
You’ve yet to read here the fuss about Julian Chan’s often spectacular presence in Tchaikovsky. Read on Black suit, white open-necked shirt. Legs splayed wide to help his balance on the piano stool as he unleashed the many Tchaikovskian assaults on the beleaguered Assembly Hall Steinway. Right foot to the sustain pedal, his left angled away towards the orchestra. His body involved in the music’s pulse even when not playing. Looking at the conductor or the soloing instrumental he duetted with. Hands usually a-blur in bravura passage work, at other times percussive onto the keys like tympanist’s flashing drumsticks.
Chan’s relish plain, for Tchaikovsky’s grandest Russian celebration and bravado as much as for his tenderness and self-doubting reserve. And then Chan’s launching at fearless speed of the finale’s rattlingly catchy Cossack dances, in the Russian village or small-town festival celebrations that are national ingredients so integral for Tchaikovsky even to begin sitting down to think though a major work.
Chan’s chamber music pedigree – he played the other week in London with legendary Florestan Trio stringmen Anthony Marwood and Richard Lester – meant the middle movement’s quiet romance was welcome familiar territory with the solo violinist and cellist. Even though only 8 bars were composed with all three in ensemble, Tchaikovsky wanted the intimacy, even though his didn’t rate these three instruments’ compatibility until later proving his younger self wrong with his own publicly treasured Piano Trio in A minor – which inspired Rachmaninov’s.
As Gibbons pointed out to the audience, harp (a piano equivalent), violin and cello were happy enough together playing love-scene pas de deux in Swan Lake (Sleeping Beauty too). Paul Willey, pitched by illness into deputising duty for the unfortunate Julian Leaper, not only to guest-lead the orchestra all afternoon, but additionally to co-create with cellist Miriam Lowbury this concerto gem movement. Her role here was a steadier rock for the excitable violin. Their orchestral chairs were angled toward the audience for it and this was our first sustained listen to her in the good many years she’s been harnessing the WSO cello section. She’s a busy orchestral and chamber freelance, but might she one day have a concerto for us?
The audience themselves underwent a reaction test, with Concerto No 1 possibly insidiously at the back of their minds. In this unfamiliar No 2, just what was Tchaikovsky going to do next? Several spells with orchestra or piano playing without each other. A huge and long fantasy cadenza slap in the middle of the first movement. Ah, another electrifying first-movement ending. Isn’t this slow movement rather better than No 1’s? The Cossack dancers weren’t found a place for in No 1 – doesn’t that rather make it poorer off?
A Gibbons concerto favourite, the conductir revealed. We heard WSO hot-blooded response, playing of a Tchaikovsky work they too seldom encounter. Orchestra, conductor and soloist advocating to a judging audience prepared to open their hearts and finding one of their emotional rewards was Julian Chan. His smiling words told them that his performance enjoyment was high on his own wanted list. That spoke of his calibre to cope with tasks and challenges in No 2.
His words in the concert run-up: “Tchaikovsky takes what he does in the First Piano Concerto and turns it up a couple of notches even further! The product is an incredibly passionate, thrilling, and contrasting work, with one of the most torrential cadenzas I will have ever had the pleasure to perform. It's been very rewarding working on this concerto, and if you enjoy Tchaikovsky to any degree, this is definitely a work worth hearing live.”
“You made it all look so easy,” was one departing woman’s tribute to his face afterwards in the Assembly Hall foyer.
His solo encore of Bizet showed deep, sensitive touch and earned him another two curtain calls. He’s already played Tchaikovsky No 1 and Rachmaninov No 3 here with Dominic Grier and the Worthing Philharmonic, to the same erupting acclaim. In this town’s flourishing new era of classical music, Julian Chan’s Interview Concert on Sunday will uncover the bright young man underneath, whom inquisitive Worthing fans now want to know and embrace.
Richard Amey
WSO ran their latest Free Children’s Music Workshop for children in the Gordon Room, simultaneously while their accompanying adults attended the concert in the Assembly Hall a few yards along Stoke Abbott Road, 2.45-5.00pm. They are for ages 9-11, to learn various instruments, create music and artwork together, all led by qualified workshop leaders with enhanced DBS checks.
Details from www.worthingsymphony.org.uk
UPCOMING CLASSICAL CONCERTS
Assembly Hall concerts - tickets from www.wtm.uk
Wednesday 20 May – ‘Rustington’s Hubert Parry – His Music, Life and Times’. Rustington Museum (2pm), Free of Charge. Reserve a seat on 01903 788478. Conductor Dominic Grier (music director, Worthing Philharmonic Orchestra) in conversation with Sussex classical journalist Richard Amey ahead of WPO’s performance of Parry’s ‘English’ Symphony in June. Including a look at the other music in this concert (see below, 7 June) and audience Q&A.
Sunday 24 May – ‘Visions Virtuosic’. St Symphorian’s Durrington Hill (2.45) – International Interview Concert: Julian Chan (solo piano), a week after the Malaysian will have performed Tchaikovsky’s big Piano Concerto No 2 with Worthing Symphony Orchestra (as above), having already done Rachmaninov No 3 and Tchaikovsky No 1 with Worthing Philharmonic in November 2023 and June 2025, and Rachmaninov No 3 with Northampton SO/Gibbons in April.
Programme (not in performing order) including Schubert, Sonata in C minor D958; Godowsky, Java Suite selection; Alkan, Aesop’s Feast; Beethoven Sonata in F# For Therese; Chopin, Ballade No 2 in F major; plus features ‘Mystery Music’ and ‘What’s The Story?’ With Guest Interviewer.
Tickets link, plus info in ‘About’ and ‘Discussion’, at: https://www.facebook.com/events/802730655476778
Saturday 30 May – Steyning Festival at Steyning Parish Church of St Andrew & St Cuthman (6.30) Worthing Philharmonic Orchestra, leader June Lee, conductor Dominic Grier, violin Yinong Xiai: Beethoven, Egmont Overture; Mendelssohn, Violin Concerto; Schumann, Symphony No 3 ‘Rhenish’. Tickets from worthingphil.org.uk or steyningfestival.co.uk
Sunday 31 May – Choral Evensong by St Mary’s Sompting Choir (directors Aedan Kerney and Mattea Leow) at St Mary’s Church Sompting BN15 0AZ (5pm).
Tuesday 2 June – Christ Church Lunchtimes (12.30): Paul Gregory guitar.
Saturday 6 June – Come & Sing Workshop and Informal Performance of Brahms’ A German Requiem. Arun Choral Society at Worthing Baptist Church (10am – 5.45pm). Led by Dr Joe Paxton. Edition Peters in German, copies available. Info or place reservation by email to [email protected]
Sunday 7 June – ‘Symphonic Variations’. Worthing Assembly Hall (3pm). Worthing Philharmonic Orchestra, conductor Dominic Grier, piano Eden Agranat Meged (see above, 20 May). César Franck, Variations Symphoniques; Mozart, Piano Concerto No 27 in Bb K595 (Meged the soloist in bothy these pieces); Sir Hubert Parry, Symphony No 3 ‘English’. The WPO with their latest piano talent from the Purley & Coulsdon Concerto Prize Final, bearing the calibre to bring two solo piano works to one concert, the first (Franck) a virtuosic one-movement concerto in symphonic clothing. Parry may be emerging from his late 20th-century unfashionability. Grier is speaking for this, and this once Rustington-based composer’s Symphony brings sun and spirit, including a finale which varies one of his own English folk-type themes.
Saturday 13 June – ‘A Garland of Song’. St George’s Church, Worthing (7.30): music by Handel, Stainer, Vivaldi, Mantyjarvi and Mozart. Tickets from www.worthingchoral.org.uk or on the door.
Saturday 13 June – All Saints Church, Lindfield (7.30), Mid Sussex Sinfonia with Paul Gregory (guitar): Bizet, Carmen Suite No 1; Chaz Hart, Blue Wave Guitar Concerto; Sibelius, Symphony No 2. Tickets on door or from www.midsussexsinfonia.com
Saturday 20 June – ‘Water’. St Michael and All Angels Church, Lancing (7.30), The Boundstone Chorus: various choral pieces inspired by this theme. Tickers from www.theboundstonechorus.co.uk
Sunday 28 June – Worthing Assembly Hall (3), Worthing Philharmonic Orchestra with Brighton 16 Chamber Choir, conductor Dominic Grier, soprano Emily Wenman, baritone Matthew Jelf. Beethoven, Overture Coriolan, Mozart Symphony No 35 Haffner; Brahms, A German Requiem (sung in German).
Tuesday 7 July – Christ Church Lunchtimes (12.30): Yoko Ono piano.