The horror of a fake AI album supposedly of your "work"
There is huge extra significance to folk singer and songwriter Emily Portman’s forthcoming album The Dominion of Spells.
She will be previewing songs from it on a new tour taking in Shoreham’s Ropetackle Arts Centre on March 13 and The Nest at Chichester Festival Theatre on March 14.
The new album is her first under her own name for about a decade. She’s been working with The Furrow Collective in the meantime.
Just as significantly though, The Dominion of Spells is her first album since the shock release last year of AI-generated recordings falsely attributed to her name. She now offers The Dominion of Spells as a reaffirmation of human creativity and connection at a troubling time for those in the music industry.
“The new album is really because I missed songwriting so much. It is really just that. I find that as much as I love singing the traditional songs that I sing and as much as I do have a fulfilling career, I just started to miss actually writing songs and it just felt there was something missing from my life. I just love the fact that you create something from scratch, that the song is not there in the morning and then it is.
“I'm calling the album a journey through the dark woods. It's a mid-life journey through the dark woods in search of wonder! There are a lot of themes but I've always been inspired by transformation and metamorphosis. I was writing at a time of a lot of change in my life. I hit 40 and I think I had my midlife crisis and for me it was basically about not writing songs, about the fact that I needed that creativity in my life. I needed that sense of awe and wonder that song-writing gives you.
“I was having a difficult time. I had some health diagnoses and I'd moved from one city to another. And just getting back to writing was comforting. I was finding a lot of traditional tales that were mirroring my own experiences, tales about transformation and change that I've interwoven into my own personal experiences.”
But there was a very nasty shock along the way.
“I was there in the middle of making my new album last July and I was in the studio when I got a little heads-up on social media that apparently I had a new album out called Orca. I was completely bamboozled by what was going on. I followed the link to the album and I found it under my profile on all the digital platforms, that I had this new album for sale under my own name. I was horrified and I thought it was a mix-up but when I clicked through I found that a lot of the actual song titles could have been assembled from what I had previously produced. I thought that I could be writing song titles that sounded like those titles.
“It just left me really disturbed. It became apparent that it was an album that has been AI-trained on my music in order to create a cheap copy. I found it very strange to listen to the music. It didn't sound like me but at the same time there were some really eerie resemblances.
“It was hard because I had no control over it. And as musicians that is what we're facing right now with the increase of AI albums coming out. A lot of the time there is no attempt to make it sound like the artist but with this it was strange because somebody had actually trained it on my music and somebody was trying to make money out of me.
“I was able to get it withdrawn. It was not straight forward with Spotify but the other platforms were great. And then it happened again. Another album was put up a few days later but that one was more like AI slop.
“But really I just think it goes hand in hand with the fact that the streaming platforms don't have musicians at their heart. They're the ones profiting from the music and for me it was an additional insult that these things can be put up. I do believe that the platforms are working on their security now, though.
“When the music was up I did feel a growing sense of anxiety that people could click on this music and mistakenly think it was me. I did find that really unsettling and I was so relieved when it was taken down but I just feel that there is no accountability for it. I can't ever get to the bottom of who it was.”