Brighton player ratings vs Man United: 5/10 midfield duo poor after Carlos Baleba decision

How the Seagulls rated in the 3-0 Premier League loss to Manchester United

Well that was all a little tame from Brighton in the end. The weather was perfect, the flags waved and the crowd were loud but the performance was flat and Manchester United were comfortably the better team.

Patrick Dorgu gave the visitors the lead with a thumping header from Bruno Fernandes' corner. It was Fernandes' 21st assist of the season - an outright Premier League record.

Ten minutes later and it was 2-0 as Bryan Mbeumo finished off a nice team move and Fernandes then made it 3-0 early in the second half after a VAR check.

Brighton's creative players were rarely in the game and at times in the second half they looked a little lost and lacked ideas to break through a very good United team, who continue to impress under Michael Carrick.

Carlos Baleba added a little life to the Brighton midfield with his introduction. Will he move to United this summer?

Brighton player ratings

Bart Verbruggen - 5: Little he could do with either of the first three goals. A nice save to deny Amad on 53 minutes

Mats Wieffer - 5: His first game back after an ankle injury. Safe with the ball and defended pretty well against the lively and physical Dorgu

Jan Paul van Hecke - 5: Still no sign of a new contract and potentially his last game for Brighton. Not the ideal way to finish.

Lewis Dunk - 5: Tried to drive forward with the ball and inspire his team but nothing seemed to come off for him today.

Ferdi Kadioglu - 6: Brighton's player of the year dealt well with Amad and bombed forward when he could.

James Milner - 5: The Milner-Gross midfield combo just did not work today. The were over ran and out played. Milner, 40, was replaced by Baleba on the hour. He’s out of contract this summer and no news as yet on a new deal.

Pascal Gross - 5: His passing didn't have the usual zip and efficiency as he struggled to find space against a well-drilled United midfield and defence.

Diego Gomez - 5: The work rate you would expect but final pass or shot was often wayward. Missed Brighton's best chance on 57 minutes when he dragged an effort wide from 10 yards. Should have scored.

Jack Hinshelwood - 5: He scored three in his last four matches but never looked like adding to that today. Brighton’s creative players just did not get going.

Maxim De Cuyper - 5: Played on the left wing and arrowed a shot just wide on 20 minutes with his right foot. the Belgian was replaced at halftime with Minteh

Danny Welbeck - 5: The former Man United striker just didn't get involved in the game at all. Replaced by Kostoulas on 59 minutes.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice