In an impressive 5-2 win, the Brazilian took his goal tally for the season to 18, with two composed penalties and a superb finish into the bottom corner from the edge of the area.
Albion had taken a two-goal lead after 29 minutes – with Facundo Buonanotte opening the scoring with a sensational long-range strike. Pedro doubled the visitors’ lead from the spot after he was brought down.
Sheffield United were undeterred, though, and managed to go in at half-time level thanks to goals from Gustavo Hamer and William Osula. Both goals were given after long VAR checks for offside – much to the home fans’ annoyance.
The Seagulls responded well and retook the lead via the penalty spot once again after Pedro’s cross was handled by Jayden Bogle. Pedro stepped up to slot past debutant Ivo Grbic once again.
Pedro – the club’s record signing at *just* £30m – scored his hat-trick, and fifth goal in two FA Cup games, with an arrowed strike from Jan Paul van Hecke’s pass.
With the hosts looking for a way back once more, substitute Danny Welbeck added the finishing touch to a rapid counter-attack with a strike too hot for the keeper to handle – sealing a 5-2 win.
The result sees Albion move onto the fifth round of the FA Cup, as they aim to right the wrongs of last season’s heart-breaking semi-final defeat.
Here’s how Brighton’s players rated:

9. Billy Gilmour – 8
Brilliant performance. Quickly becoming one of the most important players in this team. Didn’t put a foot wrong. Photo: Eva Gilbert Photography

10. Facundo Buonanotte – 8
Scored an absolute screamer to open the scoring. Could be the FA Cup goal of the season already. Was a real menace all afternoon. Photo: Clive Mason/Getty Images

11. Evan Ferguson – 7
Looked right in the mood today, as he searched for a goal to get his confidence back. Had a great header ruled out as provider Gross was offside. Provided the assist for the opener, if you can. Pressed from the front. Impact faded as the game went on before he was replaced by Danny Welbeck. Photo: Clive Mason/Getty Images

12. Joao Pedro – 10
Wow, what a player Brighton have on their hands. Scored his first hat-trick in English football to seal a memorable win. He could be the best penalty taker in Europe right now. It isn’t just about his goal-scoring, though. He was brought down for the first one after a lovely piece of skill and his cross led to the handball for the second spot-kick. His third goal was something you’d expect from a seasoned veteran. Full of confidence, stood his marker up and played in a dangerous cross which should have been scored. Photo: Clive Mason/Getty Images

