Callum Robinson had opened the scoring for the hosts just after the break. It was a well worked goal for the Baggies as Matt Phillips' header was directed into the path of Kiaran Grant.
He outpaced Albion' s Dan Burn and squared for Robinson to convert with a right footed shot.
Cedric Kipré's dismissal on 69 minutes for a foul on Leo Trossard proved decisive. The defender was already on a yellow when he hauled down the Belgian.
Albion exploited the extra space and it was second half substitute Jakub Moder that levelled with an angled left footed drive into the top corner.
Moder then turned provider when his cross was well left by Trossard and Neal Maupay rifled home at the near post to beat former Albion man David Button.
Scroll down and click through to see who shone and who struggled for Graham Potter's team.

9. Steven Alzate 6
Solid enough from Alzate and will benefit from minutes under his belt. Always played safe and was replaced by Moder with 15 to go

10. Neal Maupay 8
Cracking finish to make it 2-1. Enjoyed quite a battle with the West Brom defence and a bruising encounter. Played the the full 90 plus extra time and will rest and recover ahead of a crunch game against Palace.

11. Danny Welbeck 6
More vital minutes in the bank. First half chance for Welbeck but well saved by Button. Replaced on the hour as Potter manages his minutes

12. Alexis Mac Allister 6
Replaced Mwepu and looked sharp in the midfield. More space once West Brom went down to 10 and almost won it for Brighton just before extra time when stinging low shot was saved by Button

