Opinion: Pascal Gross is back at Brighton - but returns can be a mixed bag

Ian Hart on the return of a Brighton legend

So they say you should never go back… Well in Albion’s terms its been a bit of mixed bag over the years.

By a country mile, the best ever return has to be Glenn Murray, having previously left us in 2011 when he shouldn’t (Cheers Gus), he returned in the summer of 2016, initially on loan before making the move permanent in the season which saw the Albion reached the EPL for the first time in their history.

In his second spell, he notched up 141 appearances scoring 49 goals, cementing his legacy as a genuine Albion legend.

On the manager front, another two legends also returned, Alan Mullery in 1986 and Micky Adams in 2008 respectively.

But its was a classic case of things never being the same, and they were both unfortunately out of the door within 12 months.

There could have actually been a third ‘return’ in the dugout, fresh from sacking Russell Slade in October 2009, Tony Bloom went straight to Steve Coppell and offered him a Withdean return, only to receive a polite refusal.

Player wise, three legends also made returns. Peter Ward arrived back at the Goldstone in the Autumn of 1982 on loan from Forest, and arguably could have been in the Albion’s cup final line up had it not been for some truly narcissistic behaviour from the late Brian Clough.

The 1983 skipper Steve Forster also returned to the club in 1992, only to find a club in crisis, his Albion career effectively ending after he told David Bellotti exactly what he and the rest of us thought of him! (its all in a book currently in all good book shops )

And Johnny Byrne was another brought back in the mid 1990’s to try and bolster the Albion’s wretched fortunes but to little effect.

Obviously, yet another legend, Bobby Zamora also returned in the twilight of his career, he certainly did not let anyone down.

But he will always be remembered for the halcyon days in his first spell and back to back title wins in 2001 and 2002.

Pascal Gross is back

But the now ‘Der Kaiser’ is back, Pascal Gross, a modern day Albion legend is back in a move which to a degree has polarised the opinion of sections of the Brighton support.

The cynical amongst us, and a comment I’ve heard more than once in the last week or so, is that its an act of appeasement, Paul Barber as Neville Chamberlain? Now there’s a thought!

Carlos Baleba is going in this window, but frankly if its for £60 million I will willingly drive him to whatever club pays that!

He’s lost his Albion mojo, it happens, its time to get rid, move on, but spend the cash on someone who is EPL ready, preferably a centre forward!

So for that reason, I don’t actually buy into the appeasement conspiracy theory, I’m pleased Pascal is back.

Naivety on the pitch has cost us dear so far this season, perhaps having a wise head on the park, will see us embark on the vein of form we need to if we want to be competing for a place in Europe come the end of the season.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice