Opinion: Some Brighton fans think Hurzeler should go - but does poll result really tell us much?

Once again the late Sir Harold Wilson’s almost iconic quote about a week being a long time in politics applies to all things Albion.

At the start of last week, Albion manager Fabian Hurzeler, ahead of two very winnable games against Bournemouth and Fulham, was being lauded in the media as a potential replacement at White Hart Lane if Thomas Frank became the latest managerial casualty at Tottenham.

Brighton Head Coach Fabian Hurzeler looks on ahead of the match at Fulham (Photo by Mike Hewitt/Getty Images)placeholder image
Brighton Head Coach Fabian Hurzeler looks on ahead of the match at Fulham (Photo by Mike Hewitt/Getty Images)

A week on and the situation couldn’t be more different.

After a last-gasp draw at home to the Cherries, Albion tasted last-gasp defeat against Fulham at their supposed bogey ground, Craven Cottage.

And in the wake of the loss in London, sections of the support went into apoplexy over not only some questionable substitutions from Hurzeler but his apparent snubbing of the travelling Albion support at full-time in not doing enough to show appreciation for their backing.

Well-known Albion fan Paul Samrah took to my old stomping ground, the BBC Sussex fans’ phone-in, to express his disgust at the manager’s post-match actions and to question if there was an ongoing disconnection between the club and the supporters.

He wasn’t alone on the phone-in, and as I was one of the pioneers of this genre locally, I can state that the overall content of the show, in both good and bad times, was always a fairly accurate barometer regarding the mood of the fans.

But once the show went off air at 6pm, in the wake of the defeat, and as is now almost par for the course, the latest ‘Fab Out’ poll sprang into action on social media.

Three choices; Fab Out, Fab In, Sit on Fence. At time of going to press, over 70% of the voters didn’t want him in post, or weren’t sure. But is that figure north of 70% actually an accurate one?

Of 712 votes cast at that point, 266 wanted Fab gone immediately while 243 were still sitting on that fence. But with nearly 30,000 regulars at Amex be they season ticket holders or match-by-match spectators, those 509 votes are less than 2% of the larger fan base, so is that really a true indication of the overall opinion of the Albion support?

Clearly everything isn’t A1 – given the investment in the squad, this was the season we were going to get back into Europe. Instead with some indifferent results, it’s Fulham, a team we could and should have arguably beaten twice, instead of picking up a solitary point out of six, who are thinking about making another sortie to the continent next season for European competition.

There are very fine margins. A number of games this season might have ended in victory with the rub of the green, but most teams up and down the country could argue that.

There are 15 games left, 45 points to play for, so maybe with the aforementioned rub of the green falling in the Albion’s favour, European qualification might not be a totally busted flush.

While every game is key, I feel the next three are almost pivotal in the Albion’s season and perhaps in Hurzeler’s future at the club.

Aside from the excellent FA Cup win at Old Trafford, one victory in 10 EPL games, against lowly Burnley, tells its own story.

Back-to-back home games against Everton and Palace need a six-point return before the Valentine’s Day FA Cup game at Liverpool with its ludicrous 8pm kick off time... don’t get me started on that!

If there’s a poor showing in both the Amex games, and then a cup exit on Merseyside, the next poll might have a higher figure than 70% not saying ‘Fab In’.

But before that, and no excuses or mitigating circumstances, for Hurzeler not to properly acknowledge the travelling support, well that’s unacceptable – let’s hope Craven Cottage is the last time it happens.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice