What's happened to Georginio Rutter? Latest Brighton situation explained ahead of Leeds United return

Brighton club record £40m signing from Leeds United has had to be patient this season

It was all looking good for Georginio at the start of the season.

The club record signing had a solid first campaign in the Premier League after his £40m arrival from Leeds United in 2024. Georginio netted eight goals with five assists in all competitions and looked ready to push on further this term.

The £60m exit of Brazilian striker Joao Pedro to Chelsea also paved the way but so far this term the French striker has largely struggled.

Georginio has three goals in the top flight and has started just once in the last seven matches. Danny Welbeck has been the main man in Brighton's attack as the 35-year has 13 Premier League goals to his name.

Charalampos Kostoulas and Stefanos Tzimas (currently injured) were brought in last summer to provide youthful and energetic back up, while Evan Ferguson was allowed to go to Roma for the season on loan.

Georginio does not always look comfortable as the main attacker and the 24-year-old's best position is the No 10 role - he wears the No 10 shirt after all. His physicality and ability pick out passes and assists is more suited to that position.

At his best, the Georginio-Welbeck combination is a dangerous one and that seemed to be Hurzeler's preferred option, especially as attacking midfielders Matt O'Riley and Brajan Gruda both spent time away on loan this season. O'Riley with Marseille and Gruda with RB Leipzig.

Jack Hinshelwood is the new No 10

But just lately a new challenger has emerged in the No 10 role and the excellent Jack Hinshelwood is keeping Georginio on the bench. Hinshelwood, a Brighton academy graduate and England under-21 international, has taken his opportunity.

The 21-year-old is a versatile performer and has, for the most part, operated as a full back or defensive midfielder for the Seagulls.

He did though play in an advanced midfield roles throughout his youth career and he clearly has an eye for goal. Hinshelwood's excellent header in the 3-0 win against Wolves was his third goal in three matches.

Hurzeler: Hinshelwood has a desire to score

"He has a really good understanding of the game," said Hurzeler to Sussex World after the Wolves victory. "Really good feeling for being in the right position and right place, and then the main bit is just his desire to score, like how he attacks the opponent's box."

Hurzeler added: "He's getting the rewards but he was always a threat and it's about doing these runs all the time. He also creates a lot of space for his teammates, and he makes his teammates better by his positioning, by his desire to score, by his desire to run in behind."

Hinshelwood is clearly in the box seat and Georginio will have to patient and will likely be on the bench this Sunday as he returns to his former club Leeds United.

Hurzeler added: "He's a great team player and gives everything for this club.

"We are not thinking of taking him away from this position because he's really growing into this position.

"He's adapting, he's learning, he's adjusting small things.

"He's not satisfied with just playing and playing good games, he always tries to develop and always tries to learn new things in this position."

Georginio’s unexpected problem

Great for Hinshelwood... but it's a problem for Georginio and one he probably did not see coming.

Georginio remains a popular figure at Brighton. He has a strong bond with the supporters and Hurzeler even named Georginio as a captain earlier this season against Sunderland.

The German head coach is also a huge fan Georginio’s work rate but wants “a greater desire to score” from his French attacker.

“I'm happy how he worked for the team. It's about also getting more into dangerous areas, trying to attack the opponents’ box,” said Hurzeler when asked about Georginio last December.

“It's more like the idea and the will ‘I want to score’ with the desire ‘I really want to score’ so sometimes I miss the hunger.

“I miss the hunger to attack the opponents' box with everything I have in my body, to make this goal, and therefore we have to keep working with the players.”

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice