The Hornets fought valiantly for 69 minutes before Brad Young fired the Blues in front. Zach Clough confirmed Carlisle's passage into the second round late on.
But who stood out for Horsham? Here are Sam Pole's ratings from the game.

9. Charlie Hester-Cook - 6
Worked hard in the middle of the park, but, like Harris, he was more of a runner than a creator as Carlisle dominated possession Photo: Stu Forster/Getty Images

10. Rob O'Toole - 6
Gave everything he had at the top of the pitch but received little service as Carlisle pinned the Hornets back Photo: Derek Martin Photography and Art

11. Eddie Dsane - 6
Busy and a willing runner on the pitch but oftentimes isolated up top on his own. Photo: Stu Forster/Getty Images

12. Shamir Fenelon - 6
Replaced Dsane in the early stages of the second half but, just like him, was left isolated up front. Photo: Jon Rigby

