Crawley Town player ratings: Substitute gets an 8 as Reds get point against Latics

Tshimanga was fed through by fellow substitute Dion Pereira and the striker made no mistake, holding off Oldham defender Emmanuel Monthe and finding the bottom corner.

Ryan Loft had given the hosts the lead on 18 minutes when he lashed the ball home at the back post.

Ryan Loft celebrates | Picture: Kyle Hemsleyplaceholder image
Ryan Loft celebrates | Picture: Kyle Hemsley

The Reds should have had at least another before the break with Reece Brown coming closest. The midfielder’s lifted effort over goalkeeper Matthew Hudson struck the crossbar.

Oldham came out of the blocks flying in the second half and Michael Mellon, son of manager Micky, curled in a fine finish in the 50th minute to equalise.

Jack Stevens gave the visitors the lead after 68 minutes after being found by Mellon and duly dispatching in front of the jubilant travelling supporters.

The game came to a dramatic conclusion when the Reds thought they’d been awarded a last-minute penalty. Referee Charles Breakspear reversed his decision after consulting with one of his assistants.

Here are the player ratings:

Harvey Davies: 6 - Epitomised the topsy-turvy nature of the game. No-nonsense first half with a few smart stops but too wayward with his distribution in the second 45.

Dion Conroy: 6 - Calming presence in the back-three on his return to action. On multiple occasions was trying to settle his fellow defenders.

Charlie Barker: 6 – Solid outing from the centre-back and in amongst the drama at the death. Looked like he handballed it when the referee awarded a late penalty that was then reversed.

Harry Forster: 6 – Energetic as ever but not his most impactful game in a Crawley shirt. Played on both wings today. Could’ve had a penalty but also could’ve conceded one.

Reece Brown: 7 - One of Crawley’s best players in the first half, looking composed and creative in equal measure. Unlucky not to score when he struck the crossbar just before the break. Replaced midway through the second half.

Jack Roles: 7 – Probably the Reds’ best player until his substitution. Worked his socks off and was the key cog in the Crawley machine.

Ryan Loft: 7 – Two goals in two and held up the play really well in first half. Little less involved after the break but still challenged the Oldham defence.

Ade Adeyemo: 6 – Lively first half and linked up well with his fellow midfielders. Replaced in the second half by Pereira.

Kaheim Dixon: 6 - Very energetic in the first half and came close to scoring. Was replaced shortly after half-time in response to Oldham’s strong start to the second half.

Jay Williams: 6 – Still sporting a big bandage across his head, he didn’t have the strongest impact on proceedings. Perhaps showing a little fatigue from another 90 minutes after returning from injury.

Josh Flint: 6 – Marauding as ever in the first half, offering himself as a threat. Had to dig in defensively in the second half.

Substitutes:

Louie Watson: 6 - Came on early on in the second half and got stuck in.

Gavan Holohan: 6 – Replaced Brown halfway through the second half.

Dion Pereira: 7 – Offered the Reds a new outlet when introduced and he provided the assist for Tshimanga after tidy play down the right.

Kabby Tshimanga: 8 – Sensational off the bench again, causing the Oldham defenders all sorts of problems. Showed great strength and composure to spare Crawley’s blushes.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice