Crawley Town v Colchester United player ratings: Fours 8s for Reds but a 6 for striker who missed huge chance to win game

Crawley Town drew 1-1 with Colchester United on Boxing Day in a game where they had a gilt-edged chance to win.

Reece Brown gave Reds the lead in the first half before Kyreece Lisbie equalised.

Chances were few and far between in the second but Scott Lindsey’s men should have won it near the end but Harry McKirdy, Kabby Tshimanga and Ryan Loft all missed chances in the same goal mouth scramble.

Here are our player ratings:

Crawley Town players celebrate Reece Brown's goal | Picture: Grant Mansfield/Mansfield Mediaplaceholder image
Crawley Town players celebrate Reece Brown's goal | Picture: Grant Mansfield/Mansfield Media

Harvey Davies – 7. Possibly should have done better for Colchester’s opener, and distribution needed to be better. The Crawley number one made an impressive stop on the stroke of half time.

Charlie Barker – 7. Losing possession in an important area of the pitch was Barker’s only mistake in an otherwise good performance from one of Crawley’s star men.

Dion Conroy – 8. Made several important defensive actions throughout the game and did well against a young and quick Colchester attack.

Josh Flint –8. Displayed his usual standard of quality against a tough opposition, particularly at the end.

Dion Pereira – 7. Crawley’s most skilful and creative outlet, constantly had Colchester’s players struggling against him. Maybe should have left the game with something more to his name.

Jay Williams – 8. Mistimed some challenges which gave Colchester an opening but showed his usual fight in the midfield battle. Did well as the visitors threatened late on. Was dominant in the midfield in the second half.

Geraldo Bajrami – 7. Made a crucial tackle early on in the game and showed his usual composure on the ball. Substituted after an hour.

Harry Forster – 6. Struggled to contain Colchester’s Lisbie. Forster also failed to capitalise from a few corners. He displayed his usual energy but not his best performance. Bagged a goal although it was flagged for offside by the linesman.

Reece Brown – 8. Scored Crawley’s opener in some great play in a tight area to net his second goal for the club. Crawley’s biggest danger on the attack.

Jack Roles – 7. Displayed some beautiful play with Reece Brown for Crawley’s opener. Roles’ is occasionally a victim of his own creativity, with a few audacious pass attempts failing. Substituted after an hour.

Ryan Loft – 6. As usual showed some great work ethic, but failed to get away any real opportunity. Perhaps Crawley’s counter attacking style did not suit his profile whilst he failed to utilise his aerial threat. Missed an opportunity in the dying moments to win the game.

SUBSTITUTES

Harry McKirdy – 6. Had a few glimpses of quality but largely unaffected the game.

Gavan Holohan – 6. Quietly put in an impressive shift in the midfield, wasn’t involved in any big plays during his cameo.

Ade Adeyemo – 6. Created a great chance late on that wasn’t capitalised by three Crawley players.

Kabongo Tshimanga – 6. Had a golden chance saved late on to give Crawley the lead.

Louie Watson – N/A.

Related topics:
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice