Eastbourne Borough’s Plainmoor massacre: How bad was it – and where do club go from here?
The Plainmoor Massacre: it sounds rather like a forgotten battle from the English Civil War. But last Saturday’s 7-0 defeat at Torquay United will long be etched in the memories of Eastbourne Borough and their followers.
Supporters, reporters and club historians found themselves scratching back through the record books. For Borough as a senior non-league club, the result is matched only by an FA Cup defeat by the same scoreline, a decade ago at Braintree Town.
Far back in the 1980s, as Langney Sports, the club did lose an out-of-their-depth FA Vase tie by 8-0. But for the current fully professional Eastbourne Borough, this was a result to forget.
To the credit of club and playing staff, nobody is hiding or offering excuses. The 50 or so travelling supporters will be reimbursed, and – with no midweek fixture – the players’ training schedule will have had a pretty sharp focus.


Quite aside from the distance, Torquay is a tough trip for any visiting opponents. A large and partisan home crowd, and a daunting feel to the cavernous old-fashioned Plainmoor stadium. Tommy Widdrington has a team in transition – and the Gulls simply swooped to pull them apart.
THE SEVEN DEADLY STRIKES
7 mins: Six pink shirts in the Borough box, but Torquay striker finds the net: 1-0
20 mins: the Eastburne back line is quite high and quite square as a Gulls forward breaks to score from the edge of the penalty area: 2-0


30 mins: Just after Borough come desperately close with a strike against the crossbar and the follow-up blocked, the Gulls finesse a third goal with a smart one-two from their right wing: 3-0
45+ mins: the mountain to climb becomes a sheer rock-face as Torquay slice through the inside-right channel and a low skidding shot finds the bottom far corner: 4-0
Up and down the country, from parks to Premier League, a team losing badly at half-time will always hear the coach tell them: win the second half! If only…
57 mins: the middle of the Sports defence is vacant, and Dean Sandford – who in fairness made some solid saves during the afternoon – is beaten by a deflected shot from the edge of the box: 5-0


58 mins: from their own restart, Borough lose possession and Torquay forwards slalom through for 6-0
63 mins: another After You Cecil moment in the Boroough defence allows the Gulls in for the final time: 7-0
In fairness, and in brief lulls between the storming home attacks, Eastbourne actually had their own clutch of chances. Top scorer Pemi Aderoju netted a potential consolation, but it was disallowed. Have a heart, referee….
SOME FANS’ VIEWS
“I’ve been watching Brough for over twenty years, and that’s the most embarrassed I’ve been!” - “Recruitment is appalling, and the Big Two (Simon Leslie and Alan Williams) can’t take any criticism and blame the fans!” (and on the other hand…) “That’s what supporting a club through thick and thin is all about….”
THE OWNER’S VERDICT
I want to thank every supporter who made the long trip to Devon. Travelling that far, spending your time and money, and still backing the team says everything about the loyalty around this club. It’s appreciated more than you know.
As a club, we’re trying to make the right decisions every day. But we also must be honest: some of the decisions we’ve made haven’t given us the outcomes we expected. (Read more from Simon Leslie in his Herald column this Friday).
THE DAMAGE
So often in sport, the difference between succeeding and falling short is not ability, but the confidence and belief to succeed. This season, Borough players have been circled with uncertainty – changes of management and coaching staff, changes of playing style and strategy on the pitch, changes in the squad and team-mates.
That last issue will be a real challenge for some time yet. Widdrington inherited a hybrid squad: a few players from the 24-25 campaign, a number of summer signings, and several players drafted in by Tommy himself.
Recruitment in the summer was mixed – some experienced Matt Gray journeymen, some long-term loans from Foolball League clubs. And – with an eye to the future – two or three promising local youngsters. It echoes that piece of rural advice to the lost and disoriented motorist: “I wouldn’t start from here…”
THE ROAD AHEAD
A title challenge? Forget it. If form picks up drastically, a pitch for the play-offs would just be credible. But probably those ambitions belong on next season’s agenda. First, Borough must gather enough points, scrap for enough gritty results, to winch themselves clear of the bottom four.
That itself will be a serious challenge for two reasons. First, this season’s National South has no obvious relegation candidates. Nobody will be doomed by Christmas or by January.
The Chippenhams and Enfields will carry on grinding out their win one-lose one progress, and April’s drop-zone will be a scramble of six or eight clubs.
And second, the Sports have already donated umpteen points to the causes of their rivals. The first dozen fixtures of this season were not the most challenging, but Borough have already failed at the Lane against modest opponents – with all the Chelmsfords and Worthings and Dorkings still to come.
RIGHT MAN - AND RIGHT TIME, BUT NOT MUCH OF IT…
And yet, with all these provisos, Borough now have one of the best managers in this league – or in the division above – in post. He is part-way towards the restructuring of his squad, especially in terms of tough, experienced professionals.
Tellingly, Tommy commented the other day to local media that “I need a Tommy Widdrington out there on the field” – a proper leader, or preferably two or three of them.
Life-long Langney loyalists, new Borough adopters, sceptical observers from a distance: all will have their own point of view. In the end, the Plainmoor Massacre was just a football match, one fixture of 46 this season in the National League South. A forgettable result, but a day trip for the memories album!