The Hornets – who were making their first appearance in the second round proper since 2007 after first round opponents Barnsley were expelled from the competition due to an ‘administrative error’ – went toe-to-toe with the U’s in the first half but second half goals from Dion Pereira (2) and Omari Patrick saw the hosts book a place in the third round.
But who stood out for Horsham at Gander Green Lane? Here’s how Sam Pole viewed the Hornets’ performances.
5. Jack Strange
Imperious in the air despite dealing with a major aerial threat in the Sutton front line. Strange marshalled the defence and was a rock at the back against League Two opposition. Photo: Getty Images
6. Jack Brivio
The Hornets skipper was solid in defence for the visitors. He lead from the back and looked calm and measured when dealing with the threats coming his way from the Sutton attackers. Photo: John Lines
7. Tom Kavanagh
Kavanagh bustled in midfield, helping connect the midfield and attack. He looked composed on the ball in the centre of the park and provided a great deal of energy before being replaced in the second half. Photo: Getty Images
8. James Hammond
The maestro in midfield. Hammond looked calm and composed on the ball and worked hard to help get the ball back when not in possession. He gave everything he could for the Hornets before being subbed late on. Photo: John Lines