The Three Lions lost on penalties as Italy triumphed at Wembley - but football fans across the town - and on social media - praised the job the former Hazlewick and Pound Hill Juniors pupil has done.
Mark Howard, who watched the drama unfold at the Redz Bar at Crawley Town Football Club, said: "It was a classic game of two halves. The first half was us, the second half was theirs and extra-time could have gone either way. Penalties is always a lottery but in Gareth we trust.
"Gareth has taken us to another level and made us realise football is back again."
SEE ALSO England v Italy: Gareth Southgate s Euro 2020 final at Wembley in pictures | Sussex remains so proud of Gareth Southgate and England - despite the curse of the penalty shoot-out | England 1, Italy 1: Gareth Southgate' s England lose Euro 2020 final on penalties | Gareth Southgate on England's Euro final penalty heartache: It's down to me. I decided on the penalty takers
Colin Wenlock, who was also at the Redz Bar said: "Very gutted but they did so well to get to the final. Italy have not lost in more than 30 games and they know how to play the game, don't they?
"Gareth has done very well and I am proud to live in the town he grew up in. My kids were taught my his mother and they always said lovely things about her."
Sam Morton, who lives in Ifield, said: "They did us proud. Football still came home and brought us all together #eng #Euro2020Final"
Jacky Cook posted on the Crawley Observer Facebook page: "All I can say football did come home! We forgot our worries for a moment, we came together as a country and UNTIED and forgot our differences."
Carol Easley said: "Hazelwicks motto is effort achieves and that is exactly what England team have done for us they have achieved to get us to the final and put alot of effort in with a good manager beind them, Gareth Southgate believes in his school motto and has done exactly what a manager should do. Well done boys proud of you all."
Dee Newman said: "Gareth Southgate and England team has done us all proud in Crawley."
Soha Khan said: "Southgate will bring word cup 2022 home. So proud of Crawley’s Southgate."
Bekkie Neville said: "Just mature our young lads up a little and he could be the man to get the boys to bring home the World Cup next year!!! He got them this far !! Good on ya Gareth you keep doing exactly what your doing."
Ally Darlow tweeted: "Gareth Southgate is a national hero and there’s nothing you can do to change my mind #ENG"
Megan Norris tweeted: "#GarethSouthgate we’re proud until next year …."
Clare Chamberlain said: "#GarethSouthgate you and your squad have done this country proud be proud of yourself and your men I applaud you and the squad xxx"
Chris Haworth said: "In #GarethSouthgate I still believe. Wonderful tournament. Proud of the team. We can go further next year. #3Lions."