Where did it go wrong for Scott Lindsey in his second stint at Crawley Town?

Nothing at Crawley Town ever ceases to amaze me.

I decided to have an early night on Sunday, ready for another busy week ahead, and as you can imagine, I woke up to a number of text messages simply saying ‘Scott’s gone’.

Was I shocked? Yes. Was I surprised? No, but it did catch me off guard. Is it the right decision? Maybe.

Why ‘maybe’? I just find the timing a little bit odd.

Scott Lindsey has left Crawley Town | Picture: Natalie Mayhew/Butterfly Footballplaceholder image
Scott Lindsey has left Crawley Town | Picture: Natalie Mayhew/Butterfly Football

Given the way results have gone, most people from the outside would have thought Lindsey probably should have gone months ago. Just look at the teams around them, with Lindsey now gone, Harrogate are the only team in the bottom eight not to have changed their manager this season.

Six wins all season is simply not good enough.

So why was I shocked? When you look at how owner Raphael Khalili backed Lindsey in the transfer window, bringing back players like Kellan Gordon, Danilo Orsi, Ronan Darcy and Klaidi Lolos - getting the band back together, if you will - it felt like it was win or bust.

In November in a chat with the BBC, Khalili said: “Scott has my full backing, 100%. If we had bad people in the building and we were playing bad football, it would be a different story.

"Our playing style is extremely important to me. Scott plays beautiful football, the players respect him, he has a lot of resilience, he's the right guy to take this club where I want the club to go, in the right way."

But It hasn’t gone the way anyone wanted with only two wins since January 1.

Does the blame lay with Lindsey? As always there’s a bit of yes and no. He has to take responsibility to some extent, he is in charge of the side, the tactics, and motivating players.

But he has to be able to adapt as well and some fans were calling for him to change the formation to a 4-4-2. I don’t think that specifically was the way to go but I felt there should have been times when changes could have been made.

But again, the summer was not the best preparation with the recruitment and then the change of ownership. Lindsey highlighted that as issue when we saw the squad overhaul in the summer.

The players have got to take responsibility as well. The team in the first half of the season at times looked out of their depth and at times, lacked fight. There was a real lack of confidence and if they went 1-0 down, the heads seemed to go down and there was always a feeling of ‘here we go again’.

There does seem to be more fight from the team in the second half of the season - showcased by their three consecutive last minute/added time winners at home - but there has been a real lack of urgency at time and no killer instinct in front of goal.

Is that down to the players or Scott Lindsey? Who knows but it simply hasn’t clicked this year.

One big talking point with Lindsey this year has been referees and I do have a lot of sympathy. They have had some shocking decisions go against them and some of those decisions could have led to wins or draws which could see them further up the table.

But that’s football and I am sure other teams will have the same argument.

But do I think if Crawley stuck with Lindsey, would they stay up? Yes I genuinely think they would have.

To paraphrase Scott after the 3-1 defeat at Cambridge United while we were waiting to interview him ‘at least there are two worse teams than us’. It was a bit of gallows humour after a poor performance but he’s right. I think they would have done enough to stay up. We will never know now if they would have done under Scott but it’s make or break for whoever takes over.

As one fans said when the Lindsey news broke, ‘Blimey, need one hell of a new manager bounce and quickly.”

Related topics:
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice