Thoughts of a lifelong fan: This is why Danilo Orsi's goal against Crewe should have stood


This issue of “Thoughts of a lifelong fan” was going to contain the contents of a letter, no, an e-mail I received just after the Crewe Alexandra game on February 7.
I am afraid, that after discussion with friends and colleagues, as most of its content would have been redacted not because I don’t agree with the points made, but rather that I would prefer to try and build bridges than see them washed away with no hope of ever being able to narrow any gaps there may be between the fan base and the club in the future, we have decided not to publish the letter.
Suffice to say that it was from a retired journalist, and it absolutely brightened my evening as the email was congratulatory in its tone and urged us to carry on producing it.
Back to the game on Saturday, I have watched Danilo Orsi's disallowed goal back several times and whilst the ball may have touched his arm on the way into the net, in my opinion the ball would have ended up in the net anyway.
Here is what AI has to say about the handball laws;
When it's NOT a Handball (Natural Position)
- Supporting the body: If falling or sliding, an arm used to break the fall is natural.
- Body movement: Arms moving away from the body when running or jumping are usually fine.
- Close to the body: If the hand/arm is close to the body and doesn't significantly increase the space it occupies.
- Deflection: If the ball deflects off the player's own body (head, chest, leg) directly onto their hand/arm, it's often not a penalty.
When it IS a Handball (Unnatural Position)
- Making the body bigger: An arm extended sideways or upwards, not in line with the body's movement, makes the player "unnaturally bigger".
- Blocking a shot/pass: If the hand/arm is in an unnatural position and prevents a goal or attack.
- Deliberate movement: Moving the hand/arm towards the ball.
For me, Danilo had his arm “close to the body”, “not in an unnatural position” and he did not “move his arm towards the ball” and thus he should not have been penalised. Even if he had, the assistant, unless he has super powers, couldn’t have seen it and neither, in my opinion, could the referee have been absolutely sure Danilo had touched it.
The defenders all claimed handball, as no doubt we would have done if it was in the other penalty box, but I’m sure if it had been a defender committing the offense in their area, they would have claimed accidental handball. Scott Lindsey has said that the ref seemed uncertain whether he had disallowed it for hand ball or offside, and the referee and his assistants exited the pitch to a chorus of boos.
Luckily, all the other teams that we are currently competing with all lost, apart from, that is, bottom club Harrogate Town who beat 2nd placed Cambridge United ending their long unbeaten run. Just what we wanted, a wounded tiger coming to play us. Let’s hope we can make the injury even worse.
After the game on Tuesday I hope to attend, and perhaps ask a question, on Thursday at the Fans Forum when we get to meet our new owners for the first of many, I hope, chances to show them how much we believe in Town, Team, Together.