REVIEW: Why the Silence and the Noise at Chichester's Minerva Theatre is brutal but brilliant - as modern-day star-crossed lovers fight for survival

The opening line sets the tone for what is to come. Daize, a young woman of yet unspecified age, points the tip of a knife at posh-looking uniformed student, Ben. “I could hurt you, you know? I could hurt you and maybe I want to,” she announces defiantly.

If Ben (Joe Dolan) - with his fashionable ultra-white trainers, his expensive encased tennis racket, and enough bravado for the entire Houses of Parliament – is terrified, he does his best to shrug it off.

The Silence and the Noise at Chichester's Minerva Theatre. Photo: Alex Brennerplaceholder image
The Silence and the Noise at Chichester's Minerva Theatre. Photo: Alex Brenner

In this wilderness garden with abandoned household furnishings and appliances, an initial assessment suggests that Daize (Deborah Olat) is the protagonist and Ben her unfortunate victim.

But Tom Powell’s triumphant The Silence and The Noise at Chichester’s Minerva Theatre refuses to concede to obvious stereotyping or first impressions.

This verbal duel reveals the complexities of its cast of two through forensic and patient dissection – oscillating between banter and brutality – until the script confesses that Ben is just 14 and Daize only a year older.

Both are victims, whose lives have been blighted by county lines drug dealers – but in bleakly contrasting ways.

Ben has been signed up as a young supplier. Daize’s mother – who lives in the house whose garden the play inhabits – is the addict.

Beetle, never seen, who can be no more than 19 years old himself, is Ben’s sadistic controller and abuser and her mum’s supplier of both drugs and sex.

Ben realises too late that his own mother has been doing double shifts to pay for some extra tuition for him. She’s not abandoned him to some casual affair. By now, he’s in too deep. Beetle knows all about Ben’s family. His brother. His parents’ routines. There is no escape.

Daize cannot find a way of releasing her mother from the drug-induced hold that the gang has on her and her home.

Hopeless?

Well not quite. A bond of affection, that culminates in perhaps the most understated of hugs, builds. This is Shakespeare’s star-crossed lovers entirely reimagined.

But in seeking redemption, release and survival, together they face having to pay a terrible price.

That fee is negotiated in the brief but profound punctuations of silence which shape the play’s title too.

To achieve that level of comprehension and affinity with the audience in a performance packaged into little more than an hour, takes acting – and directing, thank you George Turvey – of the highest order.

Olat and Dolan give pitch perfect performances while Powell’s award-winning script etches with a gimlet-sharp pen the characters both on the stage and those that never step into the theatre at all. In focusing on those in the front line rather than gang leaders and the police he invests a unique perspective on a subject that TV regularly and more conventionally revisits.

For underlying it all, is the harsh reality that this is the harsh reality for far too many people. Addiction and abuse are now among the most significant causes of homelessness, hunger, and lives destroyed – even here, in seductively sweet Sussex.

Plays come in all shapes and sizes. This won’t be everyone’s cup of tea.

But this is what the Minerva was built for. It is meticulous, mesmerising, relevant drama that will keep reverberating long after the evening has concluded.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice