Community group opposes housebuilding company’s appeal after application for 80 new homes in Haywards Heath is refused
A community group has said it will fight a planning appeal for housing on what it describes as an ‘ecologically diverse site’.
The Protect Colwell Farm Action Group (PCFG) was formed by Haywards Heath residents who are against a proposal for 80 new homes on land at Colwell Farm, Lewes Road.
The original application by Miller Homes was submitted to Mid Sussex District Council in February 2025 and refused a few months later on Wednesday, September 10.
Now Miller Homes has appealed against the refusal decision. People can view their documents at pa.midsussex.gov.uk by searching for reference AP/26/0023 under ‘appeals’.


Lewes Road resident Ingrid Marson, who leads the PCFG, said: “We were all gutted to see that Millers Homes are persisting in pushing this site forward, despite the beautiful ecology of the site and how unsustainable it is for housing.”
She said: “We are determined to fight them all the way and hope to show the Planning Inspector that this site is unsuitable for housing.”
The PCFG said the site is bordered by ancient hedgerows and is ‘a haven for wildlife’, including hazel dormice, 11 species of bats, rare birds, reptiles, badgers and deer. The group said Colwell Farm has ‘various other issues’ as well as ecological ones. It called pedestrian access ‘unsafe’ and access to public transport and shops ‘poor’. The PCFG is also concerned that local services like GPs and schools will be ‘stretched’.
The decision notice for Millers Homes’ original application (DM/25/0445) said one reason for refusing it was that the development is ‘out of keeping with the rural character of the area’. It also said the site is ‘considered to be in an unsustainable countryside location’ where pedestrian access to the town centre ‘would not be convenient or attractive for future residents’. It said: “The development would result in an unacceptable intensification of development within the setting of the Grade II listed Colwell House and North Colwell Barn, an undesignated heritage asset.”


It also said: “It is not considered that the public benefits of up to 80 dwellings on the site would outweigh the harm to the setting of both the designated and non-designated heritage assets.”
The decision notice added that the homes proposal ‘would result in the loss of a significant number of trees’ too and said it ‘fails to provide the required affordable housing, the infrastructure contributions, off site highway works and the biodiversity net gain requirements’.
But Miller Homes’ statement of case in its appeal said four of the reasons behind the council’s refusal decision (out-of-keeping with rural character, unsustainable location, harmful to a heritage asset and loss of trees) were ‘not justified’. It also said the point about infrastructure contributions ‘can be overcome through completion of a s106 agreement’.
It went on to say that the appeal scheme has been ‘carefully designed to respect the site’s context and mitigate any perceived harm’ and said measures would make sure the development ‘sits comfortably within its setting and maintains ecological connectivity’. It said the site is sustainably located and can deliver ‘significant public benefits’ like affordable housing and biodiversity net gain.


It continued: “The site is well-related to Haywards Heath, benefits from existing infrastructure, and will deliver targeted improvements to enhance pedestrian safety and accessibility.”
It said: “The proposed development achieves a high retention rate of quality trees, causes no harm to ancient woodland and veteran trees, and provides robust mitigation through replanting and landscape enhancements.”
The statement added: “The proposal would deliver a minimum of 10 per cent biodiversity net gain through a combination of on-site habitat creation and enhancement, supported by off-site provision where necessary.”
The statement of case also included a ‘badger surveys’ section, which said an active sett that was monitored ‘is not within the developable area, and is located over 30m from the site’s redline boundary’.
It said: “Potential indirect impacts to badgers, associated with the operational phase, are considered to comprise disturbance by lighting, and increased recreational pressure. Due to proposed development on the site, there will be a reduction in available foraging and commuting habitat. However, as there is extensive habitat available to the south in the form of ancient woodland, the sett will not be significantly impacted by loss of foraging and commuting habitat.”
It said mitigation during the construction would minimise impacts upon badger movement and foraging behaviour across the site.
The Protect Colwell Farm Action Group, which has more than 75 members, has also told this newspaper that it has been registered as a Rule 6 party. It said this means it can fully participate in the planning inquiry. The group explained that it is ‘rare’ for community groups to take part in planning inquiries as a Rule 6 party due to legal costs. But the PCFG said it has taken on Richard Buxton Solicitors, who have a history of representing community groups and charities at planning inquiries.
