Builder comes to Horsham couple’s rescue after dream home project ends in disaster

A couple who were left homeless and around £350,000 out of pocket – after their dream home project went disastrously wrong – said a local builder came to the rescue and ‘changed our life’.

Carole and Neil Heathcote, from North Horsham, decided to transform the bungalow, which had belonged to Neil's family for decades, into a modern home for themselves and their three children.

Neil had lived at the property since the mid-1960s, and the couple inherited it after their parents died in 2022.

The third-of-an-acre plot was in an ideal location near the railway station and schools, and the couple believed it could become their dream family home.

Carole and Neil Heathcote with Rightbuild managing director Toby Gilbert and project manager Adam Foxley outside their new home in North Horsham. Photo: Rightbuildplaceholder image
Carole and Neil Heathcote with Rightbuild managing director Toby Gilbert and project manager Adam Foxley outside their new home in North Horsham. Photo: Rightbuild

Their plans included an extension and loft conversion to create a four-bedroom property where the family could live for years to come.

The couple feared their plans for a new family home were doomed after their inherited bungalow was demolished – and the builder they had trusted was unable to complete the project.

The couple were left facing a cleared building site, huge financial losses and no clear way of completing the home they had planned for themselves and their three children.

But just when they were considering selling the plot and abandoning the project altogether, an introduction through estate agents Cubitt & West led them to Toby Gilbert – managing director of Crawley-based building company Rightbuild.

The front of Carole and Neil Heathcote’s new four-bedroom home in North Horsham, which was built by Rightbuild after their original project went disastrously wrong. Photo: Rightbuildplaceholder image
The front of Carole and Neil Heathcote’s new four-bedroom home in North Horsham, which was built by Rightbuild after their original project went disastrously wrong. Photo: Rightbuild

Toby visited the site that same evening, saw the scale of the problems and decided to take on the challenge of turning what he described as a ‘disaster’ back into a home.

For Carole, 60, and Neil, 66, it was the hope they desperately needed after months of uncertainty.

Carole said: “He’s totally changed our life.

"We daren’t dream, and we still have nightmares of it, but we’re here. We’ve got a lovely house.”

Builders worked to turn the unfinished site into a family house. Photo: Rightbuildplaceholder image
Builders worked to turn the unfinished site into a family house. Photo: Rightbuild

The finished four-bedroom property, named Quarry Close, is now a far cry from the site Rightbuild inherited, with Toby describing the original work as ‘really shoddy’.

He said he became emotionally involved from the moment he met the couple after seeing the impact the failed project had had on them.

“My first thought when I turned up at the site was, this is a disaster,” he said.

“It was a mess, and the work that had been done was back to front.

Carole and Neil Heathcote outside their new North Horsham home, which they feared they would never see completed after their original building project went wrong. Photo: Rightbuildplaceholder image
Carole and Neil Heathcote outside their new North Horsham home, which they feared they would never see completed after their original building project went wrong. Photo: Rightbuild

“Then Carole explained what they had been through, financially and emotionally, and at that point I just thought, I want to help these people.

“I got involved with more of an emotional attachment than I normally would with a client.

“I could see how much damage had been done, and how genuine they were, and that’s what affected me the most.”

He said the project was unlike a typical client relationship and that he, and project manager Adam Foxley, had developed a lasting friendship with the couple.

“Once they committed to Rightbuild, I knew we were always going to deliver their dream,” Toby said.

“This was not a normal client relationship. They were on the back foot, and they honestly believed there was no way out.

The finished four-bedroom property, named Quarry Close, is now a far cry from the site Rightbuild inherited, with Toby describing the original work as 'really shoddy'. Photo: Rightbuildplaceholder image
The finished four-bedroom property, named Quarry Close, is now a far cry from the site Rightbuild inherited, with Toby describing the original work as 'really shoddy'. Photo: Rightbuild

“We have made friends for life on this project.”

Before the Rightbuild team stepped in, the couple had no way of recovering their money, and were forced to leave their unfinished home.

They initially moved in with relatives before renting elsewhere, while their possessions went into storage.

Carole said the family spent around 18 months in rented accommodation, with rent costing approximately £1,600 a month, alongside storage fees of around £1,500 a month.

The wider financial impact left them close to £350,000 out of pocket, according to the couple.

Their sons, who had graduated from university, were also left without a family home to return to.

After around 18 months, Carole and Neil began considering whether they should abandon the site altogether and move away from the area.

Carole said the builders ‘saw how devastated we were’.

"I think we sort of pulled at their heartstrings,” she said.

But taking on the project was far from straightforward.

Rightbuild had to remove the existing footings and go further back before construction could properly progress, adding an estimated £15,000 to £20,000 to the project before the work reached the company's original quotation.

Toby also faced the unusual challenge of dealing with a property caught between an existing building and a new build in planning and building regulations terms.

He said one of the hardest parts of the early stages was explaining to Carole that work completed by the previous builder had not been done correctly and that the project would need more time.

“Those were difficult conversations,” he said. “I had to keep reassuring her that everything would be alright, and I felt that with them every step of the way.”

For the couple, however, the biggest challenge was trusting another builder.

Carole said she continued to feel physically sick whenever she had to transfer money because of what had happened previously.

“You are victims then because you don’t know who to trust,” she said.

“It’s a hell of a lot of money. They could go bankrupt and it’s not even their fault; it’s out of their control.”

Toby said it took months before he felt the couple were beginning to believe the project would actually succeed.

But as the walls went up and the steel frame was installed, the couple began to see their home taking shape.

Toby added: “They turned a corner. They started believing in me and they started believing in us.”

The couple finally moved into their new home on May 1.

Carole said: “Really, until we moved in, I was forever thinking, ‘It’s going to go wrong. It’s going to go wrong’.

“I think Toby and the team had their work cut out keeping us calm.”

Toby said completing the house was an emotional moment for everyone involved.

“We went round there one evening – me, my project manager and Naomi, my marketing manager. We sat there having a few cups of tea.

“It was that sort of moment where we could say, ‘we got here.’

“It was lovely, it really was. The job’s beautiful. It’s such a nice job.”

Carole and Neil said the finished home was better than they could have imagined.

The couple said: “Rightbuild made our dream a reality.

“The whole team cared about getting it right, and the quality of the finished home is better than we could have imagined. We would recommend Rightbuild to anyone.”

The experience has left both the couple and Toby with strong views about how homeowners should choose builders.

Toby warned that an impressive website does not necessarily tell customers what is happening behind the scenes.

“Everyone can look good online now,” he said.

“Everyone can look good using AI, everyone can have a good website.

“You can look good before you’re actually good. You really can.”

He urged prospective customers to visit previous projects, speak to existing clients and, particularly for major builds, visit the builder's premises.

Carole said the experience had taught her that even apparently thorough checks could not guarantee a project would go smoothly.

Asked what she would do differently if she could return to the day before appointing the original builder, she gave a blunt answer.

“We wouldn’t have done it.”

Neil added: “I think you’ve got to get a builder from a personal recommendation.”

Despite the financial consequences of the failed project, Carole says the family now finally have what they had originally hoped for.

“You’ve got no money now, but never mind – we’ve got a lovely house.”

For Carole and Neil, Quarry Close is now the family home they feared they might never have.

Related topics:
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice