Questions asked about effectiveness of governance and risk management at Crawley Borough Council
Questions have been asked about the effectiveness of governance and risk management at Crawley Borough Council.
During a meeting of the full council, Conservative leader Duncan Crow asked for assurances after an email from a former Independent Member of the audit committee said he was denied access to internal audit reports during his two years in the role.
Atta Ul-Haque was the first Independent Member to be assigned to the committee – but he has told the council he will not be applying to continue in the role.
While he did not have voting rights, he was expected to participate fully in committee discussions, putting forward his views and suggestions to the elected members.


Mr Ul-Haque’s letter said: “While management ultimately agreed in principle to share the reports, the legal formalities imposed were so restrictive – and, I believe, applied in a discriminatory manner – that I was unable to complete the necessary sign-off process.
“Consequently, I was denied access to internal audit reports for the entire duration of my two-year engagement. When I raised legitimate concerns, the response was marked by delays in communication and a lack of direct access to the legal team, which made it impossible to resolve the matter on a timely basis.”
Mr Ul-Haque’s letter called the situation ‘deeply concerning’, adding that he was unable to provide assurance that the council’s governance, risk management, and internal control frameworks were operating effectively.
Mr Crow called the statement ‘quite concerning’ and asked audit committee chair Kiran Khan (Lab, Broadfield) what action had been taken to investigate the concerns raised.


Ms Khan, who has been committee chair for a year, said she had read the email and would take the comments on board, adding that she had ‘full confidence’ that the officers and committee members had done their jobs properly.
When pressed for assurances by Mr Crow, she added: “I was obviously disappointed to hear that these are the views of the Independent Member but I will be making sure that the committee will be functioning correctly in the future.”
A council spokesman said: “The council is very aware of the email from Mr Ul-Haque. The issue is more nuanced than was raised during the councillor questions section of full council.
“A response to Mr Ul-Haque’s email is currently being prepared. Thereafter, the council will respond to Cllr Crow’s question, and this will be shared with members.”