Pagham put up fight but lose in Guernsey – Midhurst off to winning start

Pagham’s opening fixture of the Southern Combination Premier Division season ended in defeat as two late stoppage-time goals gave Guernsey a 3-0 victory at Victoria Park, although the scoreline was considerably harsher than the performance deserved.

But there was a winning start in the same division for Midhurst – who beat Forest Row 3-0 at the Rotherfield.

Making the long trip to the Channel Islands to face a Guernsey side expected to challenge towards the top of the table wasn’t an ideal start for Pagham, but the Lions produced a disciplined and committed display for much of the afternoon and remained in the contest until the closing moments.

The breakthrough came after 32 minutes when Guernsey were awarded a penalty. Will Fazakerley stepped up and converted from the spot, giving the home side a 1-0 lead they took into the interval.

Brett Pitman strikes at goal in Midhurst's win over Forest Row | Tommy McMillanplaceholder image
Brett Pitman strikes at goal in Midhurst's win over Forest Row | Tommy McMillan

Although behind at half-time, Pagham had every reason to remain optimistic. Defensively the side had worked tirelessly, limiting one of the league’s strongest attacking outfits to a single goal, while continuing to battle for every ball.

The second half followed a similar pattern, with Guernsey seeing plenty of the ball but finding Pagham’s defensive organisation difficult to overcome.

The defining moment of the afternoon from a Pagham perspective arrived in the 87th minute. Kaleem Haitham collected possession some distance from goal and unleashed a superb looping effort that beat the Guernsey keeper.

From the Pagham bench and to supporters behind the goal, the ball appeared to strike the wheel supporting the back of the net, which sits beyond the goal-line, rather than the post itself.

Players immediately appealed for a goal, convinced the effort had crossed the line before rebounding out, but with no goal-line technology and the officials unsighted, play continued.

With Pagham understandably pushing forward in search of a late equaliser, inevitable gaps began to appear at the back. Guernsey capitalised in the third minute of stoppage time when Fazakerley grabbed his second to finally put the result beyond doubt.

Sam Murray added a third four minutes later, giving the final scoreline a far more emphatic appearance than the balance of the game suggested.

While disappointed to leave Guernsey empty-handed, there were still encouraging aspects for the Pagham management to take from the performance. The side showed excellent discipline for long periods, worked tirelessly without the ball and remained competitive against one of the division’s fancied teams until deep into added time.

Midhurst, with ex-Portsmouth, Bournemouth and Ipswich striker Brett Pitman making his debut after becoming the league’s standout signing of the summer, won 3-0 at home to Forest Row – and Pitman, almost inevitably, was among the scorers.

Danny Burroughs opened the scoring, Pitman added the second and Liam Kimber the third as the Stags began with a win.

Pagham host Lancing on Tuesday evening, Midhurst visit Wick – at Bognor – on Wednesday.

The Lions and Stags are both in home FA Cup extra preliminary action on Saturday – Pagham host Hollands and Blair, Midhurst face Larkfield & New Hythe.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice