Political opinion from A LibDem Perspective: Cutting benefits is no NEET solution

See the latest news from Your World at https://www.sussexexpress.co.uk/your-world

The ghost of Norman Tebbitt lives on. His infamous instruction back in 1981 that the unemployed should copy his father and ‘get on their bikes and look for work’ has echoed down the years and now finds a new champion in the Conservative Leader.  

Cllr Kathryn Fieldplaceholder image
Cllr Kathryn Field | Jeremy Field

In her enthusiasm to out-do Reform’s plans to slash welfare benefits she both disparages claimants and demonstrates her own callousness. No legs? No excuse, “Double amputees run marathons”, she says. Autistic? No worries, other autists “run some of the biggest tech companies”. Housebound? No exemption, “People who are housebound do wonderful creative work at home”. And who will decide whether your mental health condition is only ‘mild’ or your joint pain only ‘routine’ so that you can be denied benefits by the (probably American-owned) agency assessing your claim?

This line of argument is wrong and problematic. First, the simple maths. According to the Office for National Statistics (ONS), latest figures show there are 1.71 million people out of work but only 690,000 job vacances, so nearly 2.5 people for each vacancy.  Second, mental and physical conditions differ widely in their severity and their consequences, and their impact can vary enormously depending on factors such as what social, physical or emotional support is available. Third, around one third of NEETs (16-24 year olds not in education, employment or training) don’t even claim benefits and are, presumably, dependent on parents.   

Politicians do not have the qualifications to judge whether any individual’s mental health or joint problems are ‘mild’ or ‘routine’. There is an implied assumption among the would-be benefits cutters that many claimants are malingerers who just need to ‘shape up’. It’s true that of the 981,000 ‘NEETs’, 60% are classified by the ONS as ‘economically inactive, not working or looking for work’.  But before rushing to judgement, consider the context. These young people will have been aged 10-18 when COVID (horribly mishandled by the Conservative government) threw their education, their social networks and their whole futures into chaos. Then hot on the heels of COVID came the emergence of AI, with its widespread risk to entry-level jobs, threatening more life aspirations. Compound this with impossible housing costs, doom-laden forecasts about our environment, withdrawal of youth services…. Is it any wonder that so many young people are vulnerable to bad actors on social media, or so ready to try out the hollow promises of extremist politicians?

There is of course no single or simple answer. LibDems believe every school should have access to a mental health professional to help early intervention, and all schools should provide appropriate SEND specialist support. Job creation could be increased by improving trading relations with the EU, reducing the cost of employing young people, and encouraging apprenticeships. We need more focus on building starter homes and helping with the transition from renting to buying. Greater investment in Youth Services could help young people avoid violence and gang involvement.

Politicians have to understand the reasons why so many young people have become disengaged from ‘normal’ working life. It will not be done by bullying them out of claiming benefits but by tailoring support to help them into work. The long awaited Milburn report makes some laudable recommendations: let’s hope there is sufficient political will to implement them.

Cllr Kathryn Field

Related topics:
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice